The tight draw in the first Test against West Indies at Antigua reopens an evergreen question: does India lack killer instinct? Is the inability to grab three wickets in the last 15 overs an indication of an inability to go for the kill, an indication of the lack of penetration in the bowling? Or is a draw honourable considering the 130-run first innings the Windies took? Is it just "great" that the Indians came this far after the 1-4 defeat in the one-day series and with three rank greenhorn bowlers in S. Sreesanth, Munaf Patel and V.R.V. Singh after "resting" Irfan Pathan and Harbhajan Singh? Or are we just unrealistically expecting too much each time Team India sets on the field?