As the World Cup veers to a close, the curtain has come down on one of the finest batsmen to have walked the earth: Brian Charles Lara. But it is also quite evident that the climax is not too far away for two others, Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar and Inzamam-ul-Haq. All three arrived on the scene, in a manner of speaking, in the 1992 World Cup and all three, it seems, are likely to depart five cups later.
Experts queasy of taking a stand say we should never compare batsmen (or bowlers) of different generations. But since Lara, Sachin and Inzy were contemporaries, let’s ask who among the three was the best. Was it Lara for his supple grace, the blistering aggression, the 375, the 501, the 400? Is it Sachin, who besides 25,000 runs, was/is also a quite wily bowler? Or is it Inzy, who more times than we can count, rescued his team from crisis? Tell.
SRT definitely.
LikeLike
It’s Lara for the sheer pleasure he gave with his batting ,swivelling almost 360 degrees on his left foot and audaciuosly carted bowlers of repute; time and again saved and won matches all thro’ his career single handed and under pressure. And this alone is sufficient. From day 1 , Lara ‘WALKED’! Inzy and Sachin have never done that. Only Gilly, among modern cricketers does that.
Lara is the man.
LikeLike
Brian Lara. Brian Lara. Brian Lara. Cricket is something more than amassing runs or winning matches. It’s about the senses, and Lara pleased each one of them. His stance, his backlift, his strokeplay… all had an ethereal quality. And from start to finis he retained and conveyed a subtle insouciance that neither Sachin nor Inzamam could. The records of the former and the indomitable spirit of the latter, and the team spirit of both may seem bigger, but Lara was a jewel that lit up rather unpolished ore that he lay in. The finest two overs I saw (in Test cricket of course) was Alan Donald to Lara. In the first, White Lightning rattled the little man. In the second, he thumped each ball for four. Salut!
LikeLike
First Lara, Next Inzy……..Sachin Never!
LikeLike
None of the three. When it mattered none of the three delivered. Lara’s Windies out of the World cup (Lara’s skills were never in sight when they were called for to save Windies pride winning the World Cup in his country) Sachin’s Indian team was chased out with their tails between their legs and as for Pakistan, well, the Woolmer albatross on them! Of the three, Sachin has been hyped up for years, the golden boy of Indian cricket has become the boy of baser metal
LikeLike
One can draw comparisons with the world of Kannada Literature for these three:
Kuvempu and Lara: The creators of Epics- altho’ there were brilliant sketches in the shorter versions of poetry and cricket respectively their sense of drama seemed reserved for greater stages.
Inzy and Sriranga: the subtle interplay of grace and power, gently unleashing volcanic explosions and ‘ innovation’ being the name of the game.
Tendu and S L Bhyrappa ; Enormous output, huge strides but a sad lack of depth. Seen as lone rangers playing for their own reasons that curiously is not marching to a different drummer but more playing to the galleys and for selfish records.
!!??
LikeLike
Gaby
Swalpa jasthi thagondidheera antha kansutthey!
Kulla jothey SLB compare madtha iddheeralla!
LikeLike
Gaby, Well said
LikeLike
I am not writing this in world cup debacle anger. The best one was Lara undoubtedly for sheer reason how he steer his side to victory against some crucial matches against Aussies and others.
The second place go for Tendulkar for his ability to bat against the best attacks, Inzy will be last because i never seen his bat talk smoothly against Aussies in Australia. But against spin still Inzy was second against Sachin as Lara was brilliant in this area also.
LikeLike
Gaby… Sooryange Torchu!
How beautiful it was to compare SRT with SLB. Both are the masters of their own skills but got lesser recognition compared to others.
Somehow, I dont agree that bhyrappa does not have the depth.
its only the churumuri group which can talk about such comparisions.
LikeLike
best batsmen post-bradman era has seen,
1 SIR VIV RICHARDS
2 BRIAN LARA
3 RICKY PONTING
LikeLike
Sachin lost it somewhere around 1999. I’m told this is a true story. The great Mr. Gavaskar (and let it be known once and for all that he has nothing but the welfare of Indian cricket on his mind) told SRT during the fourth day of an ATC match being played between Ind and SRL at colombo, that he had a great chance of bettering Bradman’s Record.
LikeLike
lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara lara
aa mudi goobe sachinna yaake lara jote compare maadtiri? yelli raja bhoja yelli gangu teli!
LikeLike
So if u compare these three BATSMANtheen it is easy to say that……….. 1:Inzi and Lara were playin only for the team and country on the other hand sachin is not playing for his country just for the records……………. 2:LARA is best stylish player……………………………………………………… 3:INZIMAM ia best chaser all over the world
LikeLike
Inzamam’s total number of centuries in the test cricket is 25 of which 17 centuries have helped Pakistan to win tests and the winning percentage is 68.When the Australian skipper Ricky Ponting taking into account, from his 38 test centuries, 24 have converted to test match-winning knocks and the percentage amounts to 63.But Sachin Tendulkar scored 42 test centuries of which 16 have helped India in winning tests and the percentage amounts to only 38.The most important comparison is the number of centuries in the second innings.Out of 6 centuries of Ricky Ponting, 5 have helped Australia in winning tests and the percentage is 83.Inzamam had 4 match-winning centuries out of 6 centuries.That is 66%.But Tendulkar have scored 10 centuries of which only 3 have helped India in winning matches and the percentage amounts only to 30.
As far as aggressiveness is considered Sachin,Inzamam and Ponting is almost similar.It may be India’s load of expectations that agitates his mental toughness or is he unable to manage pressure in the middle.Sachin Tendulkar always enjoyed more, batting in the first innings than in the second innings.
LikeLike
i think inzimam is best among them becouse he is the batsman who took his team from loose to the winning position
inzimam rocks
LikeLike
no doubt salman we can’t compare any one with izni… he is second to none, he only played for the team……
LikeLike
I think sachin z so selfish while lara was inconsistent, inzamam was the only player which brought team several time from loosing position to winnig stand…… Best player in the world inzi the gr8
LikeLike
INZAMAM IS GREAT……………………………………………………………
LikeLike
sachin is incomparable
LikeLike
INZAMAM IS GREAT…
LikeLike
inzamam undoubtedly the best,sachin the most selfish n lara the most dominant
LikeLike
Sachin got century in perth1992 Is enough to say …inzi not scored even 1century vs aus throughout is carier
LikeLike