The declaration of the financial assets and liabilities, as also the educational and criminal backgrounds, of candidates was hailed as a decisive and even necessary step in cleaning up our dirty rotten electoral system. But how useful has the filing of affidavits been beyond titillating the masses? And is the Election Commission using it to ensure accountability?
On the one hand, you have the hilarious spectacle of Srikantadatta Narasimharaja Wodeyar, the imposing two-by-one scion of the erstwhile Mysore royal family, shamelessly declaring that all he possesses by way of a vehicle is a Maruti Zen. And, boy, what a tough little car that must be.
On the other hand, you have the very revealing sight of an R.V. Deshpande moving heaven and earth and everything else in between so that no journalist can use the Right to Information Act and lay his hands on his statement of assets and liabilities filed before the Lok Ayukta.
But what do you make of Kanimozhi?
The 39-year-old daughter of Tamil Nadu chief minister Muthuvel Karunanidhi, a product of one of his three wives, who has been nominated as the DMK candidate for the biennial Rajya Sabha elections, has bravely declared assets of Rs 8.5 crore.
Yes, Rs 85,000,000.
Kanimozhi says she has bank deposits of Rs 6.58 crore and a commercial building on Mount Road worth Rs 1.61 crore. Besides, she owns shares valued at Rs 3.5 lakh in Westgate Logistics (P) Ltd, a Madras-based stevedoring and terminal handling company. In addition, she says, she owns a Toyota Camry valued at Rs 18.7 lakh, jewellery worth Rs 3.61 lakh, and Rs 15,000 in cash.
Under-declaration of assets and liabilities is a national, maybe even an international, trait. (Like, a commercial building on Mount Road worth Rs 1.61 crore. Tell us another.)
Still, assuming that Kanimozhi is being as straight and honest as her father and brothers (and let us not forget their impressive cousins) the simple question that arises is: how does a little known poet, who formerly worked as a sub-editor at The Hindu, end up possessing Rs 8.5 crore in assets at the beautiful age of 39?
Do short poems pay so well?
Does The Hindu pay sub-editors so well?
Gifts? Inheritances?
Sure, Kanimozhi’s assets (financial) are not the only ones that arouse suspicion. Virtually every politician’s affidavit seems to suggest that he was laughing his guts out while filling out the mandatory form. But the point is what is the EC doing about such flagrant cases which reek of the obvious? And what is the whole point of collecting all those affidavits if it is not put to good use?
Well she may not have planned on political career, otherwise she would have shown she have a wealth no more than 8.5 Lakhs. The EC are so b****h that poor poet have to declare her known wealth.
LikeLike
I am not a fan of MK, but this sentence is in bad taste…”The 39-year-old daughter of Tamil Nadu chief minister Muthuvel Karunanidhi, a product of one of his three wives, who has been nominated as the DMK candidate for the biennial Rajya Sabha elections, has bravely declared assets of Rs 8.5 crore.”
LikeLike
brilliant insight…
LikeLike
Rightly pointed out Db. it should have read ‘ ….. an offspring from one of his three mariages ….’ or were you looking for conjugal partnerships or have I got it entirely wrong and what you thot was in bad taste was in revealing that she has been nominated to the RS or that she has been brave in declaring her assets?!
LikeLike
Now a days the best way to convert Black money into White, is to Declare your assets and enter politics through the ruling party, if it is an alliance then through one of its powerful partners!! If this really is hard earned money,
now as a honest tax paying citizen I request the IT dept, sorry the Income Tax dept, should clarify as to whether the taxes have been paid all these years. This wealth could not have been acquired over night. And she is 39!!??
LikeLike
Real estate on Mount road is very cheep now, as all of Madras is owned by one family group. Buy and sell at a cheaper rate!!
LikeLike
I agree with Dodda Buddy
LikeLike
Of the 3 people written about in this article, i’m surprised that the bulk of the article was devoted to ‘the progeny sired by a tamil politico’….
Sure, there might be discrepancies between her actual and filed financial assets….
But as far as a Flagrant breach of accountabiltiy goes… if this is what the article intends to point out… then i think Wodeyar more then qualifies as a good prime subject.
I dont dispute what this article fundamentally says…and it is Authors prerogative to choose who the subject/target is…. but is this ‘operator bias’ at play? Surely, Wodeyar’s asset-declarations ‘outweigh’ the Poet’s in inconsistency?
LikeLike
Excellent post.
The last question, “What is the whole point of collecting all those affidavits if it is not put to good use?” is spot on.
The tax authorities, even the Central Bureau of Investigation, should scrutiize all claims, tall and short, made in mandatory election declarations — that’s an easy way (1) to nip political corruption in the bud (by keeping candidates honest), and (2) to ensure the legitimacy of the election.
LikeLike
DB,
Thiru Karuna kept secret his female liaisons for as long a time as possible and only relatively recently he let the world know that he has collected ‘wives’. They are all alive. If daughter is worth so much, one could guess at her father’s wealth. Thiru Karuna is arguably the richest politician in India?
LikeLike
Ranga,
I agree–but the editor should not write phrases like …”a product of one of one of several wives..”…a product of an alumni is acceptable but lacks dignity when you refer to a daughter as a product of such…BTW I have referred to DMK as Dravida Keechaka Kalagam (DKK) :)
LikeLike
Gaby
Phrases like …”she revealed her assets…” would mean something else…Likewise I was only pointing out the arbitrariness of her birth circumstances…
LikeLike
Oh, come off it gentlemen. You seem to be nit-picking on just one line in the entire story which should have read this way or that.
Alright, ‘the offspring of one of his marriages’ has shown herself as just another human with a soul so tragically shorn of conscience; a woman, who by loudly announcing that she has monies worth a jaw dropping 8 and odd crores, absolutely without any avocation, even reasonably commensurate with the quantum of wealth revealed, from which she could have earned the very same monies, has proved that she is just another member of a class of human beings known as politicians, for whom life’s definition is woven around sleaze, deceit, hypocrisy, double-speak, debauchery and an irreperable shamelessness, that even god finds difficult to fathom perhaps!
Is this line okay, now?!
Yes, it better be. I corrected the grammar a little!
LikeLike
8 crores these days is no big deal. Any software Engineer or NRI would easily have assets worth 2-3 crores.
considering the booming RE in cities like Bangalore and Hyderabad.
or else I do not think there would villas announced everyday ‘for 3cr – 4cr’ and apartments for 1cr in cities like Mumbai.
Basically Crore has lost its value in India these days. So It is not really a jaw dropping number. that is why many politicians and film actors these days actually declare their assets as crores.
The real property would be worth some 80 crores (probably, considering the fact that Aishwarya Rai’s property is worth 400 crores or so ).
LikeLike
Taste is in the eyes of the sampler. “A product of one of his three wives,” may seem like a slur to YOU if YOU think that there is some doubt over the maternity (is there such a word?) of the child. Neither Karunanidhi nor the mother concerned nor the child, I am sure, has such a doubt.
I am second guessing here. But maybe the author’s intent was to question Karunanidhi’s conjugal liaison with three women. The man celebrated his 84th birthday two days ago. In 1947, he would have been 24. Had he married all three women by then? Or had he married all three of them by 1950, when he would have been 27?
In our quest for political correctness, we are very happy to brush aside the polygamy of our politicians, except when adherents of “the other” religion are involved. If our politicians have no respect for the law of the land in their personal lives, what can we expect from them in their public life?
LikeLike
It would be interesting to know what declarations Mr Karunanidhi, and Mr Stalin have filed before the EC?
For all the information that it collects, the EC is hardly known to have taken any action. The least it could do was to get the veracity of the information checked up, compare with the previous statements and ask the person concerned to account for the accrual of assets.
LikeLike
SoulTruth
I am willing to even go so far as to say ole Kalaignar may not have had enough ‘lead in his pencil’ trying to cope with three women and many unmentionables in his imaginative forays of “Kaadal conquers all” formula.
May be some foot soldiers in the DMK may have been the ‘real’ heroes here–who knows or do we care? Ranga and others have alluded to the fact that DMK types have been particularly blessed with extremely strong amatory appetites following a rousing Tamil oratory by the likes of Kalaignar, A Durai and other Selvans!
However, I am unhappy about the ‘product’ description. Sunaad has corrected that and the focus is on on Cunning Moley’s millions…
LikeLike
DB you are incorrigible I suppose. The last sentence in your last post is Ha ha ha
LikeLike
MK’s declaration while filing his papers last time was Rs.26 crore.
LikeLike
I did not comment on this earlier as I was not sure which of the many issues raised (intentionally or unintentionally) was more important :)
Doddi Buddhi -Hats Off to you! You made this comment trail even more enjoyable!
BNB – Just wanted to check -When you say Rs.26 crore did you mean 0.26 crore or 26 crore?
The decimal point becomes crucial here. If you meant 0.26 then the question is how can a little known poet earn much more than a well known poet CM?
Nevertheless, poetry seems to be a such a lucrative profession. :)
LikeLike
Sorry I meant writing poetry seems to be lucrative.
LikeLike
HOdudu THinnUvarige HaBBAda OOta, Dudide TinnuVarige THangalu OOta.
LikeLike
Whats wrong with you all guys? without knowing any details about kannaimozhi you are shooting your mouths as if you know all about her. no one writes poems to make money. being a poet is not a profession. Her wealth is a totally different matter. are you guys expecting a chief minister’s daughter, a ministers’ sister, a tv channel owners’ wife to have a few hundred rupees that poets get? be realistic.
LikeLike
NNN, well said…..to imagine that someone writes poems to make money….LOL
LikeLike
Triple N!
Are you completely impervious to sarcasm?
12th Month Stud!
Go ahead and imagine…
LikeLike
Do you think there is any lesson to be learnt by looking at 2 stories together – the biocon chiefs rants against UR Ananthamurthy (who is he, what did he do, implying – what wealth did he generate) and this story (some poet/subeditor, wow look at her, owns all sorts of stuff, has generated wealth)?
LikeLike
‘X’ Guy
Answer it yourself!
LikeLike
Ahhh…the ever so sensitive DB ;)
LikeLike
It looks like only government officers are booked for accumulating wealth beyond their known source of income.
Where do our politicians , retired police brass and government officers get their crorers from?
They want to become MLAs so that they can insulate themselves from the law enforcement and anti-corruption agencies.
At least Kanimozhi has a father who is the CM of Tamil Nadu and was a successful screenplay writer of the Tamil movie world.
The fact is by making a convention of this wealth declaration public, poor T.N. Seshan saab thought, the public will have the intelligence to know whose poverty these politicians are eradicating :-)
LikeLike
Rs 3.5 lakh in Westgate Logistics (P) Ltd, a Madras-based stevedoring and terminal handling company
is this why they are after ram sethu? i know they have been on it for a long time, but in the mean time they seem to be well positioned.
LikeLike
I guess Karunanidhi married only once legally. So others are not marriages or other ladies are not wives.
These ladies are called concubines by Indian Legal System.
Indian law does not recognize the legal right of a concubine to claim maintenance. They are also not treated as wedded partners. So please stop referring to Karunanidhi’s concubines as wives.
It is sickening to see a politician going scott free breaking so many laws!!! It happens only in India.
LikeLike