
PALINI R. SWAMY writes from Bangalore: There are still a few days left for the year 2007 to end, but do we already have a clear winner in the Mythological Man of the Year category?
Maryada Purushottam Sri Ramachandra aka Lord Rama.
The Archaelogical Survey of India filed a writ petition in the Ram Sethu issue stating He did not exist, and then backpedalled. Next, Tamil Nadu chief minister M. Karunanidhi called Him a drunkard and questioned His engineering skills. His (Karunanidhi’s) West Bengal counterpart Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee piped in softly, and then claimed he was misquoted.
Enter Prem, the director of hit Kannada films like Jogi and Excuse me.
Prem’s latest offering Preeti yeke bhoomi-mele ide is due for release on Friday. And like Rajiv Gandhi‘s government proscribed Salman Rushdie‘s Satanic Verses without even reading the book, the oxymoronic Sri Ram Sena has gone on the rampage even before the first show of the film, almost as if to prove the film’s title right.
Foot soldiers of Lord Rama’s Army launched by the former BJP loose cannon, Pramod Mutalik, stormed the premises of the movie’s producers Ashwini Studios today, broke furniture and window panes, heckled the producer Ram Prasad, foulmouthed the director, and warned against releasing the film.
Reason: The lyrics of the “Sullu, sullu” song in the film (sung by Kailash Kher and Shankar Mahadevan) has these two lines:
“Rama Hanuma sullu, Sita mata sullu/
Ravana kadiddu sullu, Lanka suttidu sullu”
Rough transliteration: Rama, Sita, Hanuman are untruths, Ravana‘s stealth is an untruth, Lanka’s torching is an untruth.
In a gripping two-hour interaction between director Prem (who also wrote the lyrics of the contentious song) and the “brigadier” of the Bangalore wing of the Lord’s Army, a chap called Vasant Kumar alias “Bhavani“, on TV9, the full scale of the tragicomedy called creeping censorship—the “Taliban mindset” as Soli Sorabjee put it—became clear.
Brigadier Bhavani wanted the two lines deleted. Correction, he only wanted the first line with the three names deleted; he did not seem to have any problems with what Ravana did to Sita or what happened in Lanka.
He said the lines were an insult to the Hindu icons. He claimed the lines were deliberately inserted to exploit its potential at the “box office”. He said the lines were objectionable especially at a time of mounting conversions. And he openly warned against the movie’s release with the song in its existing form.
“Taakath idre release maadi,” Brigadier Bhavani blazed on air. Translation: if you have the guts, release the film.
At Ashwini Studios, he had told a police officer very audibly: “You know what happened when Karunanidhi made his statement (two people were burnt alive in a bus). We won’t be responsible if it happens again.”
Prem might like look like a nice rustic boy in the urban woods, who got lucky when Rakshitha chose him for a life partner. But the boy from Mandya is, if nothing else, studio smart.
Have you seen the film, he asked. Do you know who wrote the original lyrics? Do you know how I chose this song? If the movie-goers of Karnataka think the lyrics are objectionable, I will cut it out.
Prem said he had been inspired by Santa Shishunala Shariff, the 19th century saint-poet.
The moment the Muslim sounding name was uttered, Brigadier “Bhavani” was flaming saffron. “We don’t believe Shariff,” he said. When TV9 anchor Ranganath Bharadwaj explained Shariff’s place in the hearts of decent Kannadigas, the brigadier backtracked. “You didn’t understand me. I only said we don’t believe Shariff wrote that.”
Prem was undeterred. He said he got hundreds of folk artists to hear the song and they had all appreciated it. And, by the way, do you know the context of the song in which these lines appear?
The context: there are two characters, clearly indicated by the choice of two singers. One of them is a believer, the other is not. The non-believer utters the lines the Ram Sena is quoting. The believer then responds with these lines.
“Hey, ninna nijave ondu sullu/
nee bayosodella sollu, nee baduko reeti sullu”
Rough transliteration: What your truth is an untruth, what you seek is an untruth, the way you live is an untruth.
In other words, the whole song is a conversation in which the believer contradicts the non-believer. In the end, the song actually underlines the existence of Rama and Sita and Hanuman, which is presumably what the foot soldiers of Sri Ram Sena want to be underlined.
But Brigadier Bhavani would have none of that creative licence. Kannada movie goers are not so mature to catch such a nuanced message, he said.
Don’t underestimate Kannadigas, warned Prem.
From Hubli, commander-in-chief Pramod Mutalik chipped in: “Why only Rama, Sita and Hanuman,” he thundered. “Why couldn’t you add Allah and Christ and say they too did not exist?” Because they do not figure in our janapada.
The wise viewers started calling in with their queries: Why don’t the Ram Sena troops do something more concrete to help Hindus, like, say, when Dalits are attacked in villages? How can you protest about something when you have not seen the actual work and context? Instead of amicably seeking the removal of the offending lyrics, how can you provocatively demand the insertion of other religious heads?
Then assorted producers and directors jumped in: Why didn’t you react all this while since the movie’s audio has been around for six months? If the censor board had okayed the film, what’s your problem? Why didn’t you approach the film chamber of commerce? Or the producer or director? Why are you indulging in this propaganda on the eve of the movie’s release? How can you indulge in this kind of vandalism and put crores of rupees at risk.
Brigadier Bhavani made vague noises. He said there had been court cases but the petitioners had withdrawn their plaints. He said the Sri Ram Sena had sent a letter to a distributor in Hubli. He said the director or producer didn’t have the courtesy to call them and ask what their objection was.
“If you knew the location of the producer’s office today, why didn’t you go there all this time if your intentions were honourable?” asked one viewer.
Struck dumb by the viewers’ (and film fraternity’s) lack of empathy to join the cause, Brigadier Bhavani was stumped. he tried to sneak in a cheap jibe on how Prem had paid Rs 60 lakh or Rs 70 lakh for Mallika Sherawat to perform a cabaret in the movie. How do you know it’s a cabaret, shot back Prem.
Finally, Brigadier Bhavani could take it no further. He said in an exasperated sort of way: “Ee prashnegalanna keluthaa iddre, nachike aaguthe.” Exact translation: Listening to these questions, I feel ashamed.
Ashamed perhaps that the “humble peoples of Karnataka” are not adding fuel to the communal kettle that is on the slow boil before the elections?
Niranthara suddigaagi noduttha iri TV9.
Cool… perhaps we should TV9 to do the same for some Muslim fundys wrt Taslima Nasreen.
It is rare to have religious “activists” such as the good brigadier humiliated on camera, and we shouldn’t pass up the opportunity to do more of the same.
How about the religious nuts who attacked Taslima in Hyderabad?
Come TV9, show us that you aren’t a cheap imitation of that pseudo-secular smooth talker, Rajdeep Sardesai
LikeLike
Their skulls are too thick to allow any subtle sarcasm inside. :D
LikeLike
Alok,
That would have to be on TV9 telugu.
BTW your argument sounds like the ‘commander in chief’s’: “Why only Rama, Sita and Hanuman,” he thundered. “Why couldn’t you add Allah and Christ and say they too did not exist?”
Prem is the man!
LikeLike
Sarcasm, OK, why only with Hindu names…people of karnataka have not forgotten the incident when a Malayalam story was translated and published in the Deccan Herald. In that story there was a name which incited a particular community and the same evening Bangalore saw the worse in its life incited by a leader. Wit, sarcasm, intellectual hypocrisy, pseudo-secularism, what not for these news hungry media people. Probably by tracing the name Rama , uttering the name, making mockery….. there are a other names select them and do it. Even if the song is a duet…select the names of other religions in comparison and see the fun. Nobodsy is questioning Prem or somebody……
LikeLike
Would be nice to know just how fond Lord Ram was of his brew and who his Mallya was. Maybe it was IMFL. In any case, the Hindu pantheon was not averse to having a happy hour when all those devotees went to great lengths to offer them “soma” regularly as a ritual.
The Puranas are in Sanskrit. It has been a while since the Mahabharatha was televised. We need to give a boost to our respect for all creeds. Given our admiration for Bollywood Suras, Asuras, and Apsaras, I humbly submit that the calumny heaped on the Lord’s character by a politician whose son is named Stalin and by a Baboo whose land is closer to Kamboj, Shyama Desh,and Malaya be countered in this wise. Why Bollywood? The ingredients for this modification of the epic are all there already. Call the product Ramlila, if you will.
.
Lord Ram is holding court, with a cuppa whatever that relaxes him. Enter MK in sunglasses bigger than his face in the form of the Tamil sage Agasthya. The guru tells the Lord that his habit of imbibing will diminish the awe and shock that his descendant MGR creates in his people by destroying evil, preparing starlets for political glory, and what have you. This has been a bad day for Ramaswamy and he is not receptive to the Muni’s objections. He is also recalling an item song/dance performed by Shoorpanakhi dressed up as Kaikeyi, mouthing the words of “Kyan Karun Ram Mujhe Budda Mil Gaya.” Raman is softly humming, “Yaaro Mujhe Maaf Karo, Mai Nashe me hoon.”
As Gandhiji–not the one from Allahabad–taught us Sathwa is the strongest force in the universe and Agasthya Gurukal has that in abundance. The Muni is ably assisted in his attempt to bring Ram back to his sober glory by none other than Hanuman, played by an actor who looks like the second son of the tragically assassinated Madam. The Muni commands Shri Anjaneyalu to head out to the mountains and locate and bring to him a certain herb with magical properties. Bajarangji commands his tailed followers to fetch him a Maruthi “pronto” (Spanish-Italian), “ek-dum” (Hindi), “zaldi” (Urdu) and also “bega” (Kannada) since what is Karnataka now used to be Kishkinda in Puranic times. The screen play can add “sheeghram” (Tamil)
The Maruchi is fetched. It is equipped with gold wings instead of wheels. In no time, the simian bhakta of Ram fetches the aforementioned herb from the Sanjeevani mountain (not to be confused with an evening paper from out town).
The Muni, although known for his fiery temper, is now all sweetness and light. He tells Ramanathan that he would like to add a magic ingredient which would make the drink the Lord is sipping even more potent. The herb, crushed into fine powder by the Maharshi’s yogic powers, is dropped into the gold cup studded with nine precious stones of different colors which glow as blindingly as the rings on the fingers of the hand that is holding the cup. One sip is all it takes.
In the next take, we see the Lord singing “Mano ya na mano yar, main peena chod diya/Ab main sharabi nahi-hoon.”
This is not copy-righted material. Use it at your own risk. My only hope that my act of devotion will give everybody “sanmathi” and help destroy communal distrust.
LikeLike
Paragraph 5, “our town.”
LikeLike
One religious nut at a time.
And as is clear from the writeup and Prem’s comments, he wasnt out to disrespect anybody’s gods – and as he explains it the song was about a dialog not a one sided harangue. Not something he wrote to rile up religious sentiments.
Yes hopefully other religious nuts next. I would really like to see someone taking up the specious arguments of Christian faith healers and evangelist preachers – when they peddle faith healing and preach hate and disdain for other people. And the Muslim clerics who come out with meaningless fatwas and indulge in public displays of intolerance and ghetto mentality.
No normal person wants to disrespect any religion – what does it gain anyone? From what little I see, most people who are religious are good people whatever religion they follow and they treat religion as a personal matter, it is only the power brokers and leaders who gain by taking things public trying to incite and spewing hate against others. ““Taakath idre release maadi” etc.
But freedom from censorship by muscle-power; critical thinking to break free from a herd mentality is a good thing.
LikeLike
It is for people to finally decide what is good for them. They get the leaders they choose.
Full credit to Pramod Mutalik and Vasant Kumar for appearing on the show and taking part in a discussion.
LikeLike
” Rough transliteration: What your truth is an untruth, what you seek is an untruth, the way you live is an untruth ”
I would have appreciated if Prem had also Included a Line regarding his Wife Rakshitha.To be fair the First part of the song could be on the same lines and ask if she was a easy going girl and of low virtue and the 2 nd Part a Fitting reply praising her modesty and virtues.
Or better still can some one ask Prem ( in the movie by way of a song ) if he was really his Father’s son and Prem can please FILL in the lines.
We still have a day for the release.Can Prem Oblige.
LikeLike
About the goons actually participating in the interview, AG havent you heard- Fools rush in where angels fear to tread and so on !They never anticipated to be proven fools on the show .
LikeLike
sathya,
Are you afraid of writing what appeared in Deccan Herald and what followed ?
It was a story about Mohammed the idiot ! It was only a character and the name was only incidental
LikeLike
Gaby,
I wouldnt term the two gentlemen as goons. They are people with a point of view and they are ready to discuss about it in a public media. Maybe they are the sort who draw their strength from a mob (‘takath iddre’ etc.), but they are free to stand up to their views in a public forum to discuss it.
The way you and I cannot understand their point of view, they probably dont understand ours. I am sure Prem could have said the same thing about their rabble-rousing, “Ee prashnegalanna keluthaa iddre, nachike aaguthe”.
Give them credit for standing up to their convictions in a civilized way (I am not linking the damage done to the film studio to this exchange in the TV studios – vandalism of others/public property is a common problem in Indian cities which will probably be the focus of some other Churumuri article).
LikeLike
Well AG if you want to be Mark Anthony ( remember the honorable men….) all power to you. I can only admire Brutus.
LikeLike
Throw the bugger and his brigade in jail. Reason will automatically enlighten him.
The only antidote to such goondagiri is strict application of the law. If a person who has blatantly ransacked private property is on TV supporting his acts, and the police are standing by hoping for a “negotiation”, and the affected parties are not pressing criminal charges, something is very wrong with our law enforcement.
LikeLike
Right on Gokulam. We have always loved ad hoc strategies and hoped our problems would just go away.
LikeLike
Indian (psuedo) Secularism is asymmetric. One rule for Hindus, another for ‘minority’. Unless this is addressed by polemecists, media (Churumuri included), politicians – Mutaliks can only grow.
Very briefly here are three examples:
1. Calcutta High Court over-turned State Govt imposed ban on Taslima’s “Dwikhandita”. The state Govt or Muslims did NOT approach the Supreme Court. A group of Muslims rioted, West Bengal Govt caved in and threw Taslima to Rajasthan, the land of “Rup-Kanwar”!.
WAS RULE OF INDIAN LAW UPHELD?
2. MLAs of MIM (an ally of UPA) rioted, and almost killed Taslima in Hyderabad.
WAS RULE OF INDIAN LAW UPHELD? WHAT’S THE LATEST STATUS OF THE CASES FILED AGAINST MIM LEGISLATORS?
3. DMK/Cong Govts banned the movie “Da Vinci Code” in Tamil Nadu, Andhra, Punjab even after it was cleared by the Indian Supreme Court.
WAS RULE OF INDIAN LAW UPHELD?
There can be 100s of examples. But would like to know Churumuri’s position on these three cases at least.
Psuedo-Seculatists are most communal. They are neither helping secularism, nor rationality/Scientific spirit, nor rule of law. They are communalizing the country even more.
LikeLike
P.S. to my account: Hanumanji finds the herb in Bababudan Giri. Local legend says the herb is now really coffee, due to transformation of it by Budan.
LikeLike
Bhaskar Chatterjee,
Yellidhyappa ishtu dina? Electioneering? Rabble rousing?
Have you watched any movie by Prem? Or any kannada movie for that matter?
LikeLike
Being an atheist myself I feel prem should be allowed to get through with his lyrics. Afterall indian philosophy has had a strong atheistic and agnostic tradition within itself.
Also I suggest to prem to include a few more lines in the song so that he can convey the atheistic message to other folks as well:
“Quran Muhhamad mathu allah sullu
Jessu Mary mathu Holy Ghostu sullo sullu”
Meaning – “Quran, muhammad and allah is a bunch of lies and Jesus mary and holy ghost are also a bunch of lies”
Let not the atheist be selective like that wacko Periyar Ramaswamy and abuse hindu deities. There are much bigger targets for atheists in the missionary religions than from a culture like Hinduism which has a good amount of atheistic and agnostic influence.
LikeLike
Seriously it is time people beat up morons like Brigadier Bhavani who try and curb someone else’s freedom of expression. Who the hell does he think he is to take cudgels on behalf of other Hindus? Was this dude really in the army sometime or is the Brigadier title like the Prof. in Prof.Nanjundaswamy?
LikeLike
It is interesting to note that Rama has been classified as a “Mythological Man”. Of course, chiefs of other religions are confirmed historic characters (with valid birth, minority certificates etc.).
LikeLike
I split myself up listening to Brig. Bhavani and Prem arguing like nuts. Poor Prem, who once even conceded ‘We too are Hindus, if anybody insults our Gods, we are with you, lets go, I will bring 10,000 men to fight’. And Brig. Bhavani was coy to this warming up. What nut-heads have we become in this country!
Jabali argues that Sri Rama was wrong… in Ramayana! And we are here, after a few millenia arguing over symbols, as if anybody, or any one body of ideologically screwed up nuts owning cultural entities like Rama and Ramayana. It was hilarious, but at the end of it all, Iwas forced to smile a tragic smile. Something is seriously wrong with us in this country.
LikeLike
Mr. Guha,
And what is your grouse with the Prof. in Prof. Nanjundaswamy?
LikeLike
None at all Anonymous Guy. Except that the Prof. though he had an illustrious academic background was not a Prof for most part of his life. On second thoughts it is not fair to compare MDN to an idiot like the Brigadier in question.
LikeLike
a very good article. where are we heading? as soli sorabji said, we are becoming taliban type.
be is taslima issue, aanudeva or this issue, why are these people getting so much enraged.
this cartoon of P Mohamud fits this situation well:

LikeLike
Thakattidre heege heli nodi saar
1. Pravadi Mohammad ge 72 hendthira? (wow)
2. Yesu christhana amma gothu, appa yaaru saar?
and if you survive, let us have a debate on Prem`s Ram!
LikeLike
JR, I am no t afraid to name the story, otherwise I could have just ignored In today’s Kannada Prabha there is a news item on P.7 which states that “They have banned a Christ Paper which called (said) Allah”. And is if to crown everything just look at Pakistan, what has happened. Any religion that doesn’t condemn violence has to put up with violence.
LikeLike
Mr. Guha,
Prof. Nanjundaswamy was a professor of law at Bangalore University. And a post graduate in law from the Netherlands. So what is the problem in calling him a professor?
As you mentioned he had an illustrious academic background and was recognized as a scholar-activist by friends and foe alike. Agree with his principles or not – he was an independent minded thinker (something very rare in our herd minded atmosphere). You dont need to call him a ‘professor’ to recognize his work. Another great son of Karnataka.
Was wondering why you bought his name up in this discussion thread.
LikeLike
Soldiers of Shri Ram Sena are picketing the theatres where this movie is being shown. I wonder if they wear masks to look like their originals.
LikeLike
ಗೋ ಹತ್ಯೆ ನಿಷೇದ ಮಾಡಬೇಕು ಎಂಬ ಕೂಗು ಈಗ ಕೇಳಿ ಬರುತ್ತಿದ್ದು ಯಾರಿಗಾಗಿ ಗೋ ಹತ್ಯೆ ನಿಷೇಧ ಎಂಬ ಪ್ರಶ್ನೆ ಇಲ್ಲಿ ಉದ್ಬವಿಸುತ್ತಿದೆ. ಏಕೆಂದರೆ ಗೋವು ತಿನ್ನುವರರು ಇಲ್ಲಿನ ಬಹು ಸಂಖ್ಯಾತರು,ಹಿಂದು ಎಂದು ಬೊಗಳೆ ಬಿಟ್ಟುಕೊಳ್ಳುವವರು ಹೆಚ್ಚು ತಿನ್ನುವುದು. ಅದಕ್ಕಾಗಿಯೆ ಇಂದು ಕೇವಲ ೩೦ ಕೆ.ಜಿ ಗಿದ್ದು ಮಾಂಸ ಇಂದು ೧೦೦ ರೂ ದಾಟಿದೆ. ಬಡವರು ಇದನ್ನು ತಿಂದು ಜೀವಿಸುತ್ತಿದ್ದರು. ಈಗ ಶ್ರೀಮಂತರೆಂಬ ಹಿಂದು ವಾದಿಗಳೆ ಇದನ್ನು ತಿನ್ನುತ್ತಿರುವುದು ಕಂಡರೆ ಶೇ೫೦ ಕ್ಕೂ ಜನ ಮುಸ್ಲಿಮರು ದಲಿತರು ಅದನ್ನು ತಿನ್ನುವುದನ್ನು ಬಿಟ್ಟು ಬಿಟ್ಟಿದ್ದಾರೆ. ಹಾಗದರೆ ಗೋವು ಯಾರಿಗೆ ಮಾತೆ ಆಬಲ್ಲಳು? ವೇದಗಳ ಕಾಲದಲ್ಲಿ ಇದೇ ಬ್ರಾಹ್ಮಣಶಾಹಿ ವರ್ಗ ತಮ್ಮ ಬಾಯಿಚಪಲವನ್ನು ತೀರಿಸಿಕೊಳ್ಳಲು ಕೊಬ್ಬಿದ ಗೂವು ಯಜ್ಞಕ್ಕೆ ಅಪ್ಋಸುವಂತೆ ಆದೇಶಸಿ ಅದರಿಮದ ಘಮಘಮಿಸುವ ಬಿರಯಾನಿಯನ್ನು ತಿಂದು ತೇಗುತ್ತಿದ್ದರು. ನಮ್ಮದೇಶದ ಬಹುತೇಕ ಲೆದರ್ ಮಾರ್ಕಟ್ ಇದೇ ಗೂವಿನಿಂದಾಗಿ ನಡೆಯುತ್ತಿದ್ದೆ. ನಮ್ಮಲ್ಲಿನ ಔಷಧಗಳಿಗೆ, ಸಕ್ಕರೆ, ಡಾಲ್ಡಾ ಮತ್ತಿತರ ವಸ್ತುಗಳಿಗೆ ಇದೇ ಗೂವಿನ ಕೊಬ್ಬನ್ನೆ ಬಳಸುತ್ತಿರುವ ವಿಷಯ ಬಹುತೇಕ ಯಾರು ಸಹ ಮರೆತಿರಲಿಕ್ಕಿಲ್ಲ ಅಂದ ಹಾಗೆ ಗೂವು ಹತ್ಯೆಯನ್ನು ನಿಷೇಧಿಸಿದರೆ ಈಗ ಯಾರಗಿಎ ನಷ್ಟ ಇಲ್ಲಿನ ಅಲ್ಪಸಂಖ್ಯಾತರಿಗೆ? ಇಲ್ಲವೋ ಈ ದೇಶವನ್ನು ಆಳುವ ಸರಕಾರಕ್ಕೂ? ನೋಡಿ ಸ್ವಾಮಿ ಇಂತಹ ಗಿಮಿಕ್ ಗಳು ಬಹಳಷ್ಟು ಇವೆ. ಇದು ರಾಜಕೀಯ ಬೇಳೆಯನ್ನು ಬೇಯಿಸಿ ಕರ್ನಾಟದಕಲ್ಲಿ ಮತ್ತೊಮ್ಮೆ ಬಿಜೇಪಿ ಅಧಿಕಾರಕ್ಕೆ ಬರುವ ಆಸೆ ಇಟ್ಟುಕೊಂಡರೆ ಅದು ಶುದ್ದ ಮೂರ್ಖತನವಾದೀತು ಏಕೆಂದು ಅದಿನ್ನು ಜೀವಮನಾದಲ್ಲಿಯೆ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಲ್ಲಿ ಅಧಕಾರದ ರುಚುಯನ್ನು ಸವಿಯಲಾರದು
LikeLike