Andrew Symonds‘ charge that Harbhajan Singh called him a “monkey”, resulting in the offspinner being banned for three Tests, shows that a term of endearment in one culture (ours) can be a racist abuse for another (theirs).
The Aussies probably do not know, or probably do know, that monkeys are sacred animals in our culture. We pray to them; we have temples in their honour; why, we even believe that they built a bridge.
In other words, if you call an Indian cricketer a “monkey” and a “bastard” during the course of a innings, as Brad Hogg is said to have done, he is more likely to take offence at his parentage being questioned, rather than his lineage.
To fill a vital blank in the education of the bloody bonzers down under, and that of the International Cricket Council, which seems intent on calibrating racism from a colonial point of view in the post-colonial era of the game, churumuri.com offers a short primer on primates in the subcontinent.
***
# We count them: The first-ever census of monkeys taken in Himachal Pradesh has revealed that the State has 378, 860 monkeys. Langurs, the larger black-faced primates, number 55,180 with female outnumbering males.
# We have specialists to catch them: Two new teams from Assam have been brought to catch monkeys in New Delhi, where a deputy mayor was killed recently after he fell from the second floor of his house while trying to ward off a wild monkey attack.
# We export them: Officials in Himachal Pradesh, who see urban monkeys as little more than nuisances who pester passers-by and steal food, may have a solution to the problem of their overabundance in the State: export them to central Asia. Tajikistan has offered to import the monkeys.
# We watch them drink booze: A group of monkeys descended on an Orissa village, quaffed pots of an intoxicating brew made of marijuana leaves called ‘pana‘ lying in the open, and then set upon the villagers, injuring three of them.
# We fight elections with them: The monkey menace in Himachal Pradesh has become a major poll plank with the contesting parties promising to make an all round effort to overcome the threats posed by roguish simians to farms and crops in the State.
# We sterilise them using lasers: Himachal Pradesh’s new BJP government is planning to train unemployed youths use lasers to sterilise monkeys in a bit to combat the aggressive primates on a war-footing.
# We make movies about them: The Kannada movie producer Rajendra Singh Babu even made a film called Kotigalu saar kotigalu (translation: Monkeys, sir,monkeys), starring Ramesh Arvind and Urvashi.
Why Hanuman Andrew should feel privileged
I hope this post doesn’t get me in front of a religious committee but the way I see it, assuming for a moment that Bhajji did call Symonds ‘Monkey’ then there was no hint of a racial slur in it. ‘Abey Bandar’ we sometimes say casually to a person who is upto some useless antics or ‘monkey business’ as it is known in the subcontinent.
Indeed, Symonds does look like he’s a step behind in the evolution process with his dreadlocks and protruding face. The zinc cream around his mouth makes the resemblance to a big and strong monkey, even stronger.
Now, if Symonds was called ‘Kaalia’ which means ‘Black’ then that would be a racial slur. But Symonds does not look like a black guy. In fact he has less pigmentation than most Indians. That is why he is not called ‘Kaalia.’ He is called Monkey. I mean, you can’t call him a Kangaroo, that’s a laughable offense and a zillion times worse than calling him anything. Does he look like a Kangaroo, I ask you?
There is a strong message in all this. Such events don’t happen without a reason. That reason is not to castigate anyone (least of all innocent Bhajji) who reminds him what he looks like. The reason is for Andrew to hire an agent and attract the attention of the producers of the new Ramayan movie to audition for the role of…Hanuman – the powerful monkey god who is worshipped by many Indians.
Symonds has the height, the build and he bloody well has the looks. I have no doubts that he will – with the blessings of Dara Singh – be the best ever Hanuman to be portrayed on Film.
Andrew, stop whining about this ‘Monkey Business’ mate. You know it was you who started this. Now make good use of it and get ready to say, “Jai Shri Ram!”
LikeLike
When it comes to insults, Indains have singular ignorance, for example about calling a black person of African or West Indian origin a ‘monkey’. While African- Americans do not know its significanceand may not react as much as black Africans or West Indian. For the latter the name’ monkey’ has a long past- the treatment at the while colonial masters who often derided them as ‘monkeys’ fit enough to live on trees. Hence throwing bananas at them and calling them monkeys is as bad as calling an African-American ‘n…..r’ or ‘cotton-picking hands’.
While Indians dismiss calling some ‘monkey’ as insult citing their culture, but yet react strongly some one calles them as’b…s’ which in the West is used almost every day, is exhibiting ‘holier than thou’ attitude. I always wondered about the abilities of Dravid or Kumble to control characters like Yuvaraj and Haribhajan. The latter has in the previous occassions behaved badly in English counties when he was an overseas player. English counties I understand exercise cuation when his name comes up for selection.
If India cancels the tour, it will not be the end of the story. The White nations plus South Africa will join together, leaving Pakistan, Bangladesh and Srilanka. In the end , there will be Indian isolation. Still ponting and his friends will play in 20-20 circuit in India and pocket money.
LikeLike
a private club plays cricket with another private club in which some players call racist or derogatory names, umpires mess around and whole nation gets agitated? Go get a life my fellow country men.
LikeLike
You forgot to mention that just like ‘Monkey’ is an endearing term in Indian culture, ‘Bastard’ is an endearing and often required term in Australian culture.
LikeLike
To the census figure on monkeys, they have to add one more…
LikeLike
Aruna, go back to horses! :P
LikeLike
(un)witty nick
With no more series (no chance of guaranteed money), I have to go and back Swami Sharanam Aiyappa!
LikeLike
Why insult monkeys by name calling Australians?
LikeLike
austrelia should be banned for playing cricket with other countries for few series
LikeLike
The Indians were specifically warned not to call Symonds ‘Monkey” before coming to Aus because it had been deemed racial, so forget all your crap about what’s right or wrong, they broke the rules! And all this talk about ‘monkey’ being a complement is a load of rubbish! When Aus toured India the crowd pulled fingers at the Aus team whilst calling Symonds ‘monkey’ – hardly a complement! Get real Indians, your team have behaved badly and by trying to blackmail the officials to let your player off is a disgrace. I hope you do play in Perth, so Aus team can hand you a good whooping and then you can head home feeling sorry for yourselves!
LikeLike
Nobody is naive enough to believe that Harbhajan was honoring Symonds by calling him a monkey. But the question is, did he?
And if he did, why is it that when an Australian calls an Indian player a bastard it is ‘good hard cricket’ and when an Indian calls him a ‘white _____’ it is not ok?
Why is it that the Australians get to decide what is ‘good natured banter’ and what is not?
LikeLike
Harbhajan and Symonds had a meeting in India after Harbhajan called him a ‘monkey’ over there to solve the problem, and the umpires warned the players including Harbhajan that racial comments would not be tolerated including the comment ‘monkey’ before this test series.
Harbhajan did say it, otherwise the players wouldn’t have reacted the way they did. Harbhajan immediately went to apologise which in itself incriminates him, because he knew it was stepping over the line!
The term Bastard is not a racist comment, yes it’s rude and derogatory, but i’m sure those type of comment have been part of cricket slander for sometime.
You know full well Harbhajan’s comments are racially based, so stop endorsing this type of behaviour! You also know full well the behaviour of the Indian crowds in India was a disgrace as well! Everyone has the right to decide what is acceptable banter, not just Australians but don’t protect racism!
LikeLike
Leroy, choose your insult:
1. Your mother is a whore
2.You monkey
You can only be called one of these. Choose wisely and carefully.
LikeLike
Vibhudi
Any word can be taken as an insult, it’s the way it’s delivered and intended that makes it offensive. The word monkey is not generally offensive, however in this instance Harbhajan knowingly used it to offend Symonds but also knew it offended him racially and that’s where he is wrong!
LikeLike
Modi, monkeys, IT-BT, cricket, media. Churumuri has little to tickle the tastebuds.
LikeLike
You did not answer my question. Which insult would you rather be called.
LikeLike
If we were standing on a cricket field and there were NO rules about insulting and hacking on each other you could call me either and i wouldn’t care because i know i could call you a ‘stupid black indian c#nt’ back. But unfortunately there are rules that state players can’t racially insult each other so that’s where the term Monkey is inappropriate.
LikeLike
Forgot to add Brahmins to the list.
LikeLike
Leroy, you STILL haven’t answered my question. It’s a fairly simple one. You don’t have to get defensive to avoid answering it. Speculations, ‘ifs’ ‘coulds’ and ‘woulds’ have no bearing on a relatively simple question. This is a buzzer round and you’re losing valuable points, my friend.
LikeLike
New Cricket Rules
1) Any INDIAN player who does not agree with an UMPIRE’S or MATCH REFEREE’S decision or is upset at any OPPOSITION PLAYER during the course of an international tour shall be allowed to return home without notice. If said UMPIRE’S, MATCH REFEREE’S or OPPOSITION PLAYER’S conduct is deemed by either the BCCI, the TEAM CAPTAIN or any LOCAL INDIAN JOURNALIST to be contrary to the outstanding human values adopted by the INDIAN population, then mandatory burning of EFFIGIES shall take place over the following WEEK to indicate to the REST OF THE WORLD how angry the INDIAN population is.
( 2 ) Any loss that the INDIAN team is involved in shall be solely the result of poor sportsmanship of the opposition side, bad umpiring or any other excuse deemed appropriate by either the INDIAN CAPTAIN or the BCCI.
( 3 ) On return from an INTERNATIONAL tour, any INDIAN player found to have not whinged during the tour shall receive a MANDATORY suspension from the national side for a period of 3 matches.
( 4 ) When fielding, if Ricky Ponting, or any other test captain without INDIAN citizenship, is asked by the Umpire for his or another player from his side’s opinion on a passage of play pertaining to a wicket, the captain shall remind the Umpire he is not to be trusted. If the captain is playing in the spirit of the game he will also suggest to the Umpire that he should in fact call on the Third Umpire to check that the INDIAN team hasn’t missed out on a run due to a no ball.
( 5 ) When fielding no team shall appeal for wickets against the INDIAN team. If the Umpire believes the INDIAN batsman to be out (through only their own flawed judgement, not the oppositions appeals), they should check with the BCCI and Indian public to make sure it was actually out and in the spirit of the game to prevent unnecessary burning of effigies and cancelling of tour matches.
( 6 ) Any INDIAN side batting second is not required to bat out its second innings if the CAPTAIN deems the score not worthy enough to chase, or a waste of the INDIAN player’s time.
( 7 ) Being the humblest and most gentle race in the world, SLEDGING shall not be allowed in any game against the INDIAN side, especially in relation their parents giving birth to them OUTSIDE of wedlock.
(8) A player is not deemed to have caught a ball until it has been returned to the bowlers hand. Any instance of the ball touching the ground (for example ROLLING OVER AND STANDING UP) will show that the player was clearly not in control of the ball and hence no catch can be claimed.
(9) Any particularly tight decisions on the last day of play called against the INDIAN team is a clear cut case of the bias against the sub-continent that has plagued the game for 40 years. Any person with a column, blog, pen or mouth should feel free to voice their uninformed and unwarranted opinions (otherwise known as sour grapes) pertaining to the Australia side, particularly the great man himself, Ricky Ponting.
(10) Should any side happen to defeat INDIA, the captain of the side shall be immediately stood down due to the complete lack of sportsmanship shown toward the INDIAN side and the game of cricket in general. The new captain shall be selected by a panel consisting of PETER ROEBUCK, JOHN BERTRAND and ROBERT DE CASTELLA.
As an aside to these rules to be adhered to during the game, all cricket supporters, officials and players world wide shall acknowledge the now painfully obvious bias the international cricketing fraternity has conspired to bring against the INDIAN cricket team. This acknowledgement shall apply retroactively, accounting for the many years of mediocre results produced by the outstanding INDIAN cricket team.
LikeLike
hey Vibhudi
buzzers, if and buts, and lil games and stuff aside….those rules are pritty bloody funny huh, had me in stitches. he he
LikeLike
To all cricket fans. New words added in dictionary !!!
Ponting: (n) (adj)
1. A substance or entity or even a person of questionable integrity
2. An act of uncivilised behaviour. [Also, pontingness (n)]
Usage: The judge was driven towards justice because he knew that the pontiff was a ponting.
Sir Bonkers said, “Don’t try to bully me. I surely can fathom the pontingness in your eyes”.
Bucknor: (n) (adj)
1. Temporary blindness leading to missing out on the obvious.
2. To be at the wrong place at the wrong time.
3. Situations leading to grave judgemental errors.
Usage: I feel bucknored by my boss; Life often throws a bucknor at you.
Benson: (n) (adj)
1. Something that legitimises a severe bucknor.
Usage: First they bucknored me and then they bensoned it! I am toast.
Also see bucknor
LikeLike
Leroy, that is ‘Sir Vibhudi’ to you, servant.
The fact that you coldn’t answer a simple question is a direct testimony to the fact that you would prefer to be called a monkey rather than have your mother called a whore.
Now, about those gazzilion lines that you have wasted here, like most aussie posters on several boards, they are poorly thought out, lack sting and are astonishingly distant from the realm of making anyone smile, let alone laugh. Yet with a stubbornness that comes only to them, these posters – like their captain – are adamant that such prose is worthy of being published while the rest of the world knows they are better off imprinted on bathroom tissues.
LikeLike
‘Monkey’ is a racist comment – lame excuse.
But the point is Harbhajan Singh didn’t utter this word in Australia.
LikeLike
Vibhudiee – just chill out…not quite sure what you’re trying to say. One minute you refer to lack of sting, like this is some big argument, and the next you say my posts aren’t flowery enough to make everyone smile…?!?
Just slow down and think out the point you want to make, remove the racial undertones and aggression and just contribute in a constructive way, rather than being vindictive. I’ve merely been trying to give a second opinion and my big post about the “new rules” was just for a laugh for everyone on the site.
LikeLike