PRITHVI DATTA CHANDRA SHOBHI writes from Oakland, California: Palaniappan Chidambaram’s Rs 100 crore gift to the University of Mysore is great news to all of us, who worry about the lack of resources at institutions of higher learning. While there has been some talk of granting Central University status to Mysore University, this grant is much needed to rebuild the crumbling infrastructure and to bring the University into the 21st century.
I can only hope that the University will be more prudent and better prepared than the Mysore City Corporation, which has squandered a loan taken from the Asian Development Bank and has shown itself to be ill-prepared to make use of grants from the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM).
So to identify areas of priority, the University administration should take the entire University community, including the alumni, into confidence. More generally, this could also be a fantastic opportunity for the University to come up with a comprehensive plan to recreate itself, now that it has a substantial grant. The University could invite its faculty members and students to write memorandums on their pressing needs. A public debate involving the community at large in townhall meetings, newspapers and blogosphere will be essential.
I realize that the University has an acting vice-chancellor but all of us also know that the University administration may not have much to offer. This has to be a movement from below, both to produce a vision for the University and to identify areas of priority. Moreover, we all have a responsibility to ensure the grant administration is transparent and above the board.
In that spirit, let me make the following suggestions:
The first priority has to be to the University library (and the department libraries too), which is in a disgraceful state. The collection needs to augmented, catalogue computerized entirely, and the infrastructure completely modernized. There are also serious maintenance issues, starting from the completely incompetent and uncooperative employees. The University Library badly needs trained personnel, who are computer literate and are well versed in using electronic databases. We cannot have untrained attendors in the library, who if transferred within the University might be relocated to clerical duties elsewhere or will be bringing tea to faculty members.
The library also needs to subscribe to electronic journal databases. It is absolutely essential to buy subscriptions to JSTOR and such databases, especially to facilitate research. We need to take advantage of concessional rates that are often offered to third-world universities.
An enhanced Computer lab, which offers enough Internet enabled computers to students, is also a must so that the students could access these electronic databases along with hundreds of thousands of digitized books, all of which would absolutely crucial in enhancing the quality of education and research in Mysore University.
I know that both the Information Systems and Library Sciences departments have some really good faculty members, who need to be used extensively to modernize the library and to train library staff, University faculty and students in using electronic databases. It is not enough to create this infrastructure, if faculty and students aren’t taught how to use it. Conduct workshops and training programs, extensively.
A second area of priority has to be the science labs. Even with my limited knowledge, I know that the quality of labs is uneven. If applied botany and geology have been building their infrastructure through grants and foreign collaborations, the same hasn’t been true of other basic science departments.
Thirdly, we now have an opportunity to redefine the University’s publishing mission, by radically re-envisioning Prasaranga and introducing new ways of publishing. Prasaranga must become an IT hub for the University, an important site for Kannada software development as well as open source publishing movements. It should no longer should be wedded to publishing only printed books but consider online publishing, especially encyclopedias.
This would be truly the way to bring into the 21st century the institution building work that Kuvempu, Javare Gowda and Ha. Ma. Nayak accomplished since the 1950s.
I could go on and on. For now, let me just say: rebuild libraries and labs, and be innovative in fulfilling Prasaranga’s mission. While you are at it, wire the campus and turn Manasagangothri into a wireless hotspot. If the kids have money to buy fancy bikes, they will buy laptops too.
I know some of my suggestions seem fanciful, if not wasteful and impractical. They are not and they don’t cost too much money, especially wiring the campus and modernizing the library.
I also know that the University faces much more acute problems of infrastructure. Maharaja’s College, for instance, doesn’t have a fax machine in its office. That’s simply scandalous. The University administration could consider giving more money to its colleges and departments for contingency spending and to ensure the basic infrastructure.
Hundred crores is plenty, if spent wisely.
Let the planning and dreaming begin.
OK, agreed. 100 crores. In the Chidu budget. Gentleman, Mysore University alone will not get that amound , it will be distributed amongst many other universities, let us not imagine too much. By the time the University gets a few crores it will be another academic year.
LikeLike
Amen. I bet the bloody bureaucrats would have already started scouting spaces for filling them with big buildings and simultaneously filling their pockets too!
LikeLike
Perhaps ban caste based appointments, to the extent they can be? Find vice chancellors who are true lovers of knowledge and, yes, wisdom?
LikeLike
Let them repaint Maharaja’s college and give it some respectability. I cringe every time I pass by the pink edifice. University libraries, labs need to be given a thorough overhaul. The VC or whoever should stop putting up ugly concrete structures in every vacant spot.
More importantly, get the doyens of the university to remove the cobwebs constricting their minds…Will the 100crores be able to do it?
LikeLike
I think the author is completely unaware of the things happening at Mysore University.
Manasagangotri Campus is completely networked. All the departments are connected and have access to online journals like JSTOR and many more under the INFLIBNET scheme.
If applied botany and geology have been building their infrastructure through grants and foreign collaborations, the same hasn’t been true of other basic science departments.
How did you arrive at this conclusion? Please do not speak unless you know of the facts.
As regards students buying laptops rather than bikes, try telling that to students. It is not easy. Not all are rich to afford the laptops.
LikeLike
JSTOR subscription which was sponsored by Ford foundation, supposedly, must have expired and has not been renewed, from what I hear from my friends in the univ.
Computer Centre with more computers should be sufficient for the poor students.
LikeLike
Basic sciences have decent infrastructure but humanities block sucks the most and I don’t think the Law dept. has access to any of the legal databases(or there may be ONE or TWO computers having access)!
LikeLike
UoM is piggybacking on the success of the physics department. nothing wrong. that is actually the way to go and here’s to wishing many more successes.
aparatus and facilities is the easiest indent to make. you go to MIT, Boston and ask them and they will say they are facing resource crunch, not withstanding all the grants it receives. i think the basic idea should to invest in people instead of paraphernalia.
any grant should be against a thoroughly detailed proposal and trackable metrics and deliverables perhaps based on a double blind review of the proposal.
having said all this, i do have a certain pet projects.
#1. adminstrative –> reservations and subsidized fees apart, what would it take to make UoM, Mysore function like UoM,Amherst for example? I am talking administrative and structural issues only. With the money that is there can anything be done to the metastructure? academic autonomy, research culture, tenure based on metrics etc etc… there a million things wrong with the US, but the meta structure of their graduate education is the best in the world. we would do very well to emulate, no no, blindly copy that structure(why re-invent the wheel?).
(now one can ask if autonomy & tenure are really the way to go when, even shobhi maastar is talking of peons to deliver tea/kapi to professors. if this is the plight of peons, imagine the plight of happless graduate students. bacchal mane toLasdiddre saaku. alla, if univ profs behave like this, even as they wax eloquent on egalitarianism and other sundry theories, then god save the country. but all this is a piTeel that chowdiah’s grampa played, forget about the politics for a moment. lets play dream dream)
#2. ok physics is doing something. but with the money that is there can atleast 5 out of the more than 40 departments of UoM be made the #1 goto knowledge sources on certain topics. say school of music on the fine arts in KA, zoology+botony become THE to-go sources for all the bio-science about the southern 1/3rd of the western ghats(UoM, M’lore does the middle 1/3 and KU,Dharwad the northern 1/3), physics does particle physics, geology does moole moole of our our seeme and so on.
a mix of universal and local issues.
task#1. ID 5 fields.
task#2. ID 15 people who have more to say than ‘i need computers’ in these 5 fields.
task#3. ask them about metrics.
task#4. do what they say needs to be done.
task#5. wait 5 years (time for a nominal PhD). if metrics achieved, ok, otw. kick these guys out goto #1.
#3. math department could perhaps use some help to rework a program in applied math-some solid stats(poach people from ISI), a bit of cool stoch-with an eye on financials, a few in dynamics and modelling, some doing cool stuff like simulation and all… sow people. do ditto in other departments.
#4. but perhaps the most important thing is to seed in a culture of dissemination. shobhi maastara’s idea about prasaranga etc are right on the money. very very important and very crucial. they can start a few electronic journals. if you are not going to create knowledge atleast manage it. university poster days, a stall at dasara and perhaps even in a float in the procession. seed more than an utilitarian and existential idea about learning, knowledge and university in the minds of lay mysoreans and their kids. more than ‘yoorge kavite oliyolla, yoorge oliyutte’ type of nonsense. seed first principles not theories.
all in all the university should become a nerve center of intellectual activity mostly in the service of its immediate geography. idakke yen maadbeku, neev heLi.
40xn professors in the 40 departments in the university and yet how many participated in JNNURM discussions? How many said anything about chamalapura? How many ever have anything to say about anything related to Mysore? but somebody challenges some idealogy and all these professors crawl out of the woodworks and start emitting high frequency noises, some on the bunds of kukkralli, some on stages, others in papers. real, practical bread and butter stuff like chamalapura, nurm, water etc not one squeal.
LikeLike
Just make a survey as to how man faculty members visit the University library. ask them about the new books/ publications that have come in their subjects. The only machine that is making profit in the library/campus is the Xerox machine.
LikeLike
I agree with the idea that investment should be on people rather than on paraphernalia. Of late whenever there is some considerable grants are received (project or whatever), the concerned person(s) with the blessings of higher-ups rush to build buildings which are unmanageable after say 3-4 years. We do not see any person talking on this pitiable state. The more foundation stones that carry your name, the better you are.
Prasaranga, for some strange reason, is caught in a time warp. The Directors are always chosen from the Kannada Department and more often than not are not the ideal persons to run it effectively. It can be safely presumed that they have never thought of releasing their collection of books under Creative Commons license. In fact, there was a petition requesting the UoM to do so. Nobody knows what came of that.
When the faculty of the University are in such a blissfully ignorant state, not much can be expected in creative ways of functioning.
LikeLike
M, awesome idea about CC. honest to god, i too was thinking about it. a journal where UoM profs, students etc can publish articles. prasaranga need not print it, put it online using open source content management and operating software. if any field say geology catches on make a new journal.
Is it possible that there is a UoM blogsphere? anything that is not directly political (i love you HDK/SMK), non-personal(My wife was pissed because …). you can review the last kutcheri in kuvempunagar but you cant talk about ganesh’s marraige, though you can debate if accident was noir or not. somebodies term paper on the life in mysore pre-wodeyar days, another guy’s take on the variability in education standards as function of class. god knows what all people can write about.
CC content. if it catches media’s fancy let them publish it. ok otherwise too. i mean, internet penetration is only going to increase.
You dont need too much money, I mean, most journals reviewers, editors, etc etc are volunteers anyway. and it should not be too difficult to find students who want to publish and professors who want to rant on.
so M, is it doable? how do you seed in the idea that prasara is an important anga of an university?
LikeLike
oh! btw, perhaps they can rope in grad students and ug kids to do the tech stuff too. on a stipend even.
LikeLike
sorry for spamming your e-boxes.
shobhi sir you need to chime in too. let us in on your ideas and reactions. the way it works in the blogworld is that the author is the comment-or too.
very egalitarian medium this is. it is also highly non-positional. if it is only the ideas that are important to you, you can always qualify your position and revise it too. no problem.
so what if a blathering idiot or two is pissed with what you write, atleast you are alive, responsive and original, other acads i have seen here are all about reputations and making correct statements rather than honest statements.
In my very humble, even if un-solicited opinion, IMHEIUSO, that is he position any honest person would take unless one is seeking mumukshatva.
its a brave new world. march on.
LikeLike
TS,
> perhaps they can rope in grad students and ug kids to do the tech stuff too. on a stipend even.
No good. I personally know very few who would step up to do that job.
As regards your observation of someone being pissed off, I cannot see anyone getting worked up. I think we are having a decent discussion here (maybe too lame by some of the churumuri thread standards :-) )
LikeLike
i guess that is where reality hits the ceiling. :)
but then, since when has any university been about what is? isn’t it always about what can be? and since when has any prof been scared of showing the moon. :) (i remember being seduced by my ug prof and later being left to stand alone, knee deep in fast moving waters, even has he coveted his new bride. was fun and all, but came dangerously close to destabilizing– imagine dealing with vagaries of a under identified dynamic system as a pimply teenager, as if wraping your brains around transforms was not enough)
there are a whole lot of systemics that need to be set right before all this work. but can sweeten the pot with a promise of recos, a folio perhaps and the rest. try hoping the road and see if any of jce kids bite. perhaps across the city some kids at NIE or the JSS? Any school/ PUC kids you can tap into?
i myself dont know much, but from what little i know it is not something you shouldn’t be able to get going if you spend a week or two. if you are trying to do any of this, i beg you to not give up.
LikeLike
I nominate P. Shobhi for the V-C chair on condition that his offspring be barred from seeking the position.
LikeLike
Eveenin the second week of March, the UOM is headed by a Temporary Vice chancellor. Anaatho daiva rakshakah…….
LikeLike
Has the University announced how it plans to spend the money?
LikeLike
did you read about the open library initiative at gulbarga?
LikeLike
No. Where can I find the info?
LikeLike