E.R. RAMACHANDRAN writes: As per Wikipedia, there are 109 definitions of “Terrorism” and the only common characteristic that is agreed upon is that terrorism involves violence and the threat of violence.
Yet, politicians in our country find it difficult to define terrorism.
It is only in India that we have gone so deep in defining terrorism that there could be half-a-dozen post graduate students working on their PhD in any of our famous universities at any given point.
Quite a few studies are probably conducted with funding from the human resource development ministry which thought they must come out with the mother of all definitions for ‘Terror’, so comprehensive it should defeat the purpose of a terrorist and make him sick and tired of trying to master all the definitions and hand himself over to the first commando in the vicinity.
One way of combating terror is to set up a good intelligence network, train and equip your forces, marshal all the resources and try and root it out. This is the no-nonsense approach which most nations adopt.
The other way is make the definition of terror so exhaustive that it should exhaust a studious would-be-terrorist so much that he drops the very idea of becoming one. This method is non-violent and helps particularly when elections are around the corner.
We seem to be following this method.
Most of us know words such as ‘Islamic Terrorism’ came about after the Bali explosion and 9/11 mayhem in New York and attack on our own Parliament. Recently ‘Hindu Terrorism’ was added to the lexicon after it emerged that Hindu organisations might have had a hand in the Malegaon blasts.
So far so good.
But why stop at this, ask our mandarins of Home Ministry. Thank god there is already alleged ‘Christian Terror’ to kill Swamis and ‘Buddhist Terror’. But is that enough? We need to go deeper into the cause of terror to solve the problem.
“Is it fair or just to club all the perpetrators of terror under one religion? What if they are from different sub-sects or sub-castes?” asks our friendly official from the Home Ministry in charge of Intelligence.
Calling something as ‘Islamic Terror’ is by itself incomplete and stupid. What if some of them are ‘Sunnis’ and ‘Shias’? Shouldn’t we have studies of ‘Sunni Terror’ and ‘Shia Terror’?
Can our curiosity get quenched merely by saying ‘Hindu’ Terror? ’What about ‘Brahmin Terror’ and ‘Non-Brahmin terror’? These are intelligent questions raised by Shivaraj Patil and the whiz kids he was working with till this morning.
“We can fight terror only if know how many castes, sub castes, OBCs, non-OBCs etc are there itching to take up terror as a profession,” said an official of the HRD ministry who is working in tandem with home ministry and had offered to educate the Commandos, NSGs, ATS about the categories of terrorists available at any point of time. They need to know this before they learn to defuse a bomb or a grenade or jump off a helicopter.
We need to know the probability of ‘Vokkaliga Terror’ or ‘Lingayat Terror’ that could one day damage Vidhana Soudha, or the odds of ‘Babburkamme Terror’ one day setting fire to Basavanagudi temple.
Similarly could ‘Adi Dravidar Terror’ or ’Vishnu Terror’ gobble up Kanya Kumari temple? Can you ignore the ‘Iyengars’ with their ‘Sankethi brand of terror’ and ‘Iyers’ with an equally ferocious brand of ‘Vadama’ brand? ‘Reddy terror’ or ‘Kamma’ terror’ could one day take over the temple at Tirupati and cause mayhem. The possibilities are mind-blowing and bone-chilling.
Can our commandos drawn from different parts of country speaking different languages, yet, capable of fighting as one unit and ready to take on anybody, fight the multi-caste, multi sub-caste terrors spouted by our politicians?
Can our NSGs and ATS who can fight nonstop terrorists for days at a stretch, fight the venomous poisons injected by the politicians like the MNS, the vote mongers of the Congress, BJP, Mayawatis, Lalus, Karunanidhis, Jayalalithas and Mulayam Singhs?
That is what the common man wants to know.
Do you think our commandos, NSGs and anti terror Squads have any chance against so many terror sects sprouted by our politicians who have only one mantra which is to get votes at any cost even if it be at the cost our country? Even if it be at your cost?
I am waiting for Arundhati Roy’s article condemning NSG/Navy/Army operation against terrorists in Mumbai. Only two magazine publish such articles. Outlook (which everybody reads) and Tehelka (nobody reads! may ask her to write.
Also, waiting for Teesta Sewtalwad to file PIL s in the Supreme Court.
LikeLike
“I, a Brahmin, descendent of those who followed untouchability; now I show the same attitutude towards the Sangh Parivar?” – Thus Spake Ananathamurthy.
I call this Brahmin Terror. Silly narrow minded terror. The guy shamelessly supported the killers of security office MC Sharma in Delhi.
LikeLike
Meaningless to discuss such silly things in Churumuri. Stop asking which kula/gotra/nakshatra. Nobody has colected the details. Just look at the number of terror attacks and the no of people killed, no of people arrested. Collect statistics and come to a conclusion. That doesn’t need any HRD.
LikeLike
All those media louts who went on an overdrive about “Hindu Terror” are not even using the phrase “Muslim Terror”.
LikeLike
This piece shows why Indian media is part of the problem while we continue to bleed from terrorism. Its in self-delusion, have no guts to call the name of the evil—jehadi terrorism—by its name.
Shame on such media.
LikeLike
ERR
idu sarcasmge time alla…… This is very silly.
LikeLike
While we’re on the topic of politicians:
1) That double dealing bastard RR Patil has said: “Mumbai jaisi bade bede shaharon mein yeh choti choti baatein hoti rehti hain” (such ‘small-small’ incidents keep happening in large cities like Mumbai). So, this ass cannot even ‘mouth platitudes’ now, the minimum and only expectation we have from politicians. The rage on the streets of Mumbai at this statement was well covered by the media. Hope they make this a front page headline tomorrow.
2) That skunk of a CM, Vilasrao Deshmukh took his actor son Hritesh Deshmukh and the director Ram Gopal Verma along with his official entourage to see the ruined Taj Mahal hotel. Literally converted the place into a picnic spot. I don’t want to see the son and his bastard politician father dancing together in the next RGV film. Please, everyone flood the news channels and other media houses with SMS and mails to force that Italian woman to kick this ruffian out of the CMs chair at once.
3) That illiterate villager Laloo Yadav says, “Role of the opposition is suspect”. I wonder what he means, I can only guess. Cunning rogue, he makes ambiguous comments so that one does not even get a chance to shout at him.
4) Marathi Manoos Raj Thakeray has not said anything yet. Good. I appreciate that.
These are the kind of gems we have at the helm of affairs. Even God cannot help us.
LikeLike
Thankfully Patil is now out. And these are the very people who say on the one hand that terrorism has no religion, but on the other want to divide it into sub-castes. At least the BJP doesn’t say such things – that terrorism has no religion. For them, terrorists are clearly only Muslim. And now Karkare has gone, they will continue to make this argument, with even greater force. And God help us all when Advani becomes our next PM in May…
LikeLike
The article is frivolous, makes mockery at a time of grave tragedy. It is tasteless to say the least.
To answer the question of kula, gotra and nakshatra of terrorists:
There are two clans:
1. One operates in the north east, professing christianity, financed by foreign countries, and the christian missionaries are the idealogs. Their aim, Kurnvanto North East Christian (we shall covert entire north east a christian territory).
2. The other operates in the rest of India, and parts of north east too, professes christianity, considers it meritorious to kill infidels like the Hindus and the Buddhists and Jainas, also financed by foreign countries, especially Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. So called sufi saints are the idealogs, their aim, convert India into Dar ul Islam. The strgety is two fold: keep killing infidels, and fast breeding of muslims to overpower demographically.
3. The third may perhaps be retaliatory terror, as yet in the baby nursery of terrorist schools. No foreign finance, idealogy is to survive in their country origin, India that is, Bharat.
LikeLike
Very silly writing.
Is this a time for you write this kind of an article?
I pity your sense of humour!.
LikeLike
We know from Pakistan as to how bad the situation can go out of hand if a country tries to uses terrorism to fight its enemies rather than using the army. Let India not get into the business of terror. Nip the hindu terrorists in the buds.
LikeLike
I agree with Sandesh, “idu sarcasmge time alla……”. Its easy make fun of such attacks or to praise NSG/ATS, but difficult is to be part of those nation savers.
LikeLike
Wow, people have become extra sensitive all of a sudden. At the end of the day this is what we will get folks and things wont change anytime soon.
Do you think in the next election people will vote based on real issues, that matter to everyone and not their own self serving interests? The “Change/Yes we can” fever is still very high I guess …
The things are so bad and so deeply ingrained that if the change has to happen, it will be a violent transormation and nothing less. Are folks ready for that?
LikeLike
Desh ki dushman ko goli maro! No caste creed for a traitor. He is a traitor. Show him how it pains others.
LikeLike
When a sharp shooter wins an Olympic medal, he is showered with chrores of Rupees and real estate by all the state and the central government, but when another sharp shooter dies fighting the terrorists in trying to save the life of the Citizens of India, he and his family is compensated by a few lacks of Rupees and sympathy by the government and the people and the media. What a shame!!??
LikeLike
I agree with Sathya. What happens after resignation? The fellow goes home? Nice retired life? No cost?
There must be a mechanism whereby such rogues are handed over for public hearings and then a judge should be able to mete out punishment.
In our country, resignations = punishments because this dries up perks and monetary “benefits”. Change here is needed.
LikeLike
If the Deputy Chief Minster of Maharashtra thought he was making a pathbreaking news by his inconsiderate and crass remarks that must have incensed the whole nation, the Chief Minister makes a poor spectacle of himself by going on ‘terror tour’ of the Taj with his son and the film maker Ram Gopal Varma to restore his downhill recent film venture to make a killing in Bollywood on the death of 200 people in terrorist attack This is the mentality of the politicians that has let down India and their hangers on which include, criminals, police and corruption ridden bureaucracy. When the country pays homage to loyalty and efficiency is a much despised commodity while corruption is ruling the roost it is no surprise that country is open to all sorts of danger. It is time that civil society rebels and force the govt to try such people in public trial and award summary punishment for resignation is no punishment. Amongst these villians the only heroes are the military, RAF, NSG, Commandoes etc who have been ex[posed to face the bullets while our politicians lord over and go around surounded by z category security. For example as per media reports Rs 940 crore was spent for upgrading security equipment in Maharashtra which was used to buy cars, construct palatial buildings etc while the firefighting personnel were equipped with helmets which could only stop hit by stones and the bullet proof jackets were all rusted that cost the life of the people facing the terrorist guns. Some media too must share the blame for they came in the way of rescue work rushing around with their camera and allowing the crowd to gather seemed to indicate that some thamasha was going on and paid dearly with their life by stray bullets. Lessons have to be learnt allround
LikeLike
“I, a Brahmin, descendent of those who followed untouchability; now I show the same attitutude towards the Sangh Parivar?” – Thus Spake Ananathamurthy.
Attitudes like this make me understand why Nixon called Indians a “defeated” race.
LikeLike
Resignation should not be the answer. All politicians must be made to stay and face the realities of their leadership. Easy to resign and run away from the responsibilities.
LikeLike
I disagree Larissa. A sufficiently cold blooded Hindu nationalist is the need of the hour. Won’t take long in coming. There are some signs already, for those who are sensitive enough to know.
LikeLike
@Pallahahi
I am saying that Ananathamurthy displays the kind of attitude which caused Nixon to make that unpleasant remark. As long as HIndus remain passive they will be a “defeated” race. Their passivity throughout history has lead them to be in such a state, and even now they are divided amongst themselves and they display no unity unless something directly affects them.
LikeLike
@Pallahahi
You seem to have misunderstood what I was saying. I am saying that Ananathamurthy displays the kind of attitude which caused Nixon to make that unpleasant remark aoubt HIndus. As long as HIndus remain passive they will be a “defeated” race. Their passivity throughout history has lead them to be in such a state, and even now they are divided amongst themselves and they display no unity unless something directly affects them. Any culture which is unable to protect itself from agression and does not fight for its survival does not deserve to survive. It has been the case throughout history.
LikeLike
This article is in poor taste. Like others mentioned, there is a time and place for everything.
LikeLike
We are not Babburkamme. We are BBC.
LikeLike
good comment…..
Nice reading keep it up
LikeLike