K. JAVEED NAYEEM writes: A great deal of my work as a physician involves much interaction with elderly people especially because most of my practice revolves around diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease, the inevitable bane of most people who happen to step into the wrong side of a long enough life.
With the rapid improvement that we are seeing in health care, especially over the past 50 years, life expectancy is showing an upward swing.
When you add to this the declining population of youngsters, due not only to our national policy but also because of our own personal constraints of providing well for our children, we are seeing a rapidly changing scenario of a demographic balance that seems to be tilting towards a society with a growing population of elderly people.
When you deal, like me, with problems concerning elderly people, you are bound to make some very startling and even disturbing discoveries as I recently did.
Some time ago I asked an elderly but a highly educated and very well-to-do man coming to me with complications of uncontrolled diabetes and the associated depression, why he was not able to comply with my instructions about his medications and follow-up visits.
After a moment of introspection he looked deep into my eyes with a sad smile and said:
“Doctor, my problem is not something your medicines can treat. It is far beyond their reach. My problem is of dear ones not being near and near ones not being dear.“
His reply stunned me and opened my eyes to see beyond his obvious affluence that I thought should have solved the health problems that were plaguing his life.
The man was an elderly widower whose two very caring children were both settled abroad but who had taken pains to provide him with all amenities including his own house, an efficient housekeeper, a car with a driver and a constantly replenished bank balance that should have looked after all his material needs and kept him happy.
But happiness and the drive to live seemed to be nowhere near his life.
When he had no one to share his life with, his existence seemed bereft of all meaning and purpose which left him with no point in caring for himself. Despite all our training of looking for a hidden cause behind every disease or disorder, very often we doctors tend to overlook even some very obvious causes of some very common problems.
Very often, especially in elderly patients, a medical problem does not stem just from a medical cause but originates or gets aggravated and complicated by the loneliness, boredom, sense of insecurity and depression that form a vicious circle in their lives.
That is why most elderly people who get a much greater amount of attention especially by the nurses during any hospital stays, tend to dread going back home where they can only look forward to their loneliness for company.
So, some time ago when I saw an advertisement in Star of Mysore about someone planning to start a ‘Day Care Centre’ for elderly people, like a baby-sitting arrangement for tiny tots, I was a little curious to find out more about it.
What I found out about it turned out to be a pleasant surprise. It was being launched as a public service venture, initially on a small experimental scale by Dr Anya, a doctor, and her husband Kulwanth Singh, a food technologist whom I have known very closely over the past 25 years.
They had always struck me as a slightly different if not odd kind of couple with a significantly greater concern for the world around them than for themselves. They have started this facility on a ‘no loss no profit’ basis at their house in Vijayanagar III Stage under the name ‘Aalana’ which in Punjabi very appropriately means a nest, especially of the weaver bird.
While some facilities do exist in Mysore by way of some old-age homes to look after the aged and infirm on a long-term if not permanent basis, the Singhs felt that there was no facility that served as a day-care centre to look after senior citizens from morning to evening on a daily basis, when their children go about their daily work.
To me it seems like a unique concept as I do not know of any such venture either here or even in any other city including Bangalore. So although it may seem like a very unusual kind of service it looks like there is a role for it which people might begin to appreciate and avail of once they come to know about it.
The Singhs plan to take about eight people under their care to start with and then expand when demand picks up.
I am told that they have been having more enquiries from people who want to know if they can leave their aged dependents with them for a few days if they have to be away from town for a weekend or for a slightly extended period and are therefore preparing themselves to provide this kind of care too.
The thought that there is a medically qualified doctor supervising their care helps to give the inmates and their family members too an enhanced sense of confidence and security as there will always be someone to guide them about their symptoms and medications.
While they can be kept occupied and free from boredom by encouraging their hobbies and interests through group activities, they can also benefit from periodic lectures and workshops about healthy and purposeful living.
In a television show which I watched about elderly people some time ago, an octogenarian said that the plight of elderly persons with no one interested in caring for them was like of the ageing bird that evokes the comment “Woh parinda jise parwaaz se fursat hee na thi, ab akela hai to hamari deevar pe aa baitha hai…” (The bird that had no time to stop soaring in the skies when young, has now chosen to perch on our house when it is aged and lonely).
A very sad reflection indeed. I hope a few more nests like ‘Aalana’ will make the evening of life more meaningful and easy for some birds whose chirping had once joyously heralded the morn.
Anya and Kulwant Singh can be contacted on mobile phone number: 94-498-55246
K. Javeed Nayeem is a practising physician who writes a weekly column in Star of Mysore, where this piece originally appeared.
Best story I read today. Very inspiring. Long live Anya and Kulwant.
(PS: And I called my parents!)
LikeLike
All depends on how we raise our children, family values we pass on. This is a political question which will become more and more important in the coming decades in india.
In the west, pregnancy outside marraige, teen pregnancy have reached a level where its not sustainable anymore. families have been destroyed. net effect will be catastrophe like Europe becoming Eurabia within next 3-4 decades.
Promotion of uncontrolled consumerism, vulgur, values unfriendly to family values like Valentine day by media and political parties for scoring political points- are not helping either.
LikeLike
right now I am in nyc but the thought of being with the elderly in my home town of Surat always stays at the back of my mind…. not only my parents but when I see so many parents who are happy that their children (who by no means are selfish or uncaring) are abroad pursuing their dreams but just cannot be with their parents enough…. i see so many of them around my home….so many
hope someday ill be able to do something bout it…. just be with them!!
LikeLike
So sad to read this, really. Where is our culture when it comes to our parents?
I see so many people in bangalore who leave their parents here with a chauffer driven car in a nice apartment with cook and yet they are so lonely and only look forward to their kids coming down here or them going there to see them and spend time them.
Some have literally adopted some street urchins who come and eat at their place or watch tv, just for them to have some company.
Thank you for this writeup and I sincerely hope that punjabi couple have not found just another business opportunity in our great Indian misery and Iam afraid that it would be really true.
LikeLike
Well I call my parents often and I don’t do it out of any obligation. But let me give some counterpoints to consider and this is from observation of various relatives and friends. Perhaps the saying “DooraDa betta nunNagay” applies here.
Some parents can not live peacefully with their now-adult kids. Every day is a new battle. Everything the son/daughter/daughter in law does is a mistake . Why do you pay so much for the maid ? Why is my chapati not cooked enough? Why do you waste money for taxi? Why do the grandkids go to swimming class? Why is the granddaughter not covering up her arms?
They cannot adjust to the changes of the new gen. And this gen gap will be constant, nothing new really.
The smart parents adapt to the new technology and manage to get along with the different experiences. And they also learn to respect that what they went through does not apply to these times.
I wish the old age day care people well. I just hope this place does not end up as a war zone, opinionated oldies fighting with each other over issues like burnt chapatis and high daycare fees!
LikeLike
These are the issues which we need to address in today’s society. I congratulate Dr.Nayeem for penning this article and to Churmuri for posting it.
I also feel that all of us should blog on issues which can be addressed and create a healthy society and not on issues which are divisive and spread hatred in the society.
LikeLike
Nothing will be more satisfying than the company of our own off springs.But not all will be fortunate to have their childern living with them and that too taking proper care. It is one off the many ironies of life. Any way such center has opened is it self heart warming. Let it grow in all its colours.
LikeLike
Thought-provoking feature. Yes, the increasing life expectancy on one side and the brain-drain on the other side are causing a lot of problems in the society. The present generation (aged between 40 and 70) is sandwiched between the older generation and the demanding younger generation. If people as old as 70 and 75 are left to take care of their older generation aged 90+, without any support from their children, imagine their problems! There are a lot of such families in India now. Of course, as we get older we want to be nearer our children and if our children are away in some far off land, we cannot even join them, as we are still left with the responsibility of taking care of our parents and parents-in-law. When do we lead our lives? Though the community living arrangements seem very harsh and pathetic, that is the heavy cost of breaking up of joint families and increasing migration towards cities.
The Nightingales run a day care centre for the elderly and I was told even the BBMP has a day care centre for the elderly somewhere near Langford Town. But if we live far away from these centres, it is not feasible to transport the elderly everyday to these centres. Most of the elders are ailing, home-bound or sometimes bed-ridden.
This is a great social challenge and the entire society has to think of the best ways to see that all the three generations are happy.
Sudha Narasimhachar
LikeLike
thathaghata
Why can’t you play with a straight bat?
Why do u blame all Indian ills on West?
I agree with Putti.
There are many parents who are wilfully choosing to stay away from their children. Apart from the daily dose of squabbles, elderly parents are expected to look after the grandchildren too.! Feed them, send them to school. monitor their homework, get them cleaned and dressed,…its a mega chore..they have already done it once, when they were younger, why give them suffering in old age too?
LikeLike
I think this is a typical small city problem. I have elderly relatives in mysore and none of their younger generation are residing there. There are almost no job oppurtunities for qualified professionals in a city like Mysore (except the training centre of Infy). Most of the young and educated professionals from mysore have moved on to other cities. I think this is the same story in other small cities – hubli, shimoga, Mangalore, sagar etc. We have localized growth in only in tier 1 cities of India.
LikeLike
This is a touching and interesting article for me. My elderly parents choose to live in an old age ashram in Mysore inspite of several of my siblings offering to take care of them. It’s because my parents have always been independant and don’t like to trouble anyone (even though their children don’t think they are trouble, with some exceptions). I do feel sad though that I can’t be there as I am 10,000 miles away. On another note, very glad that Dr. Anya and her husband are doing this. It just so happened that I went to school with Anya in Mysore and hadn’t heard anything about her till now (in 28 years!).
LikeLike
good article even i am wooried about my mom who is working in mysore and i am residing in dubai i aggre with sophist my husband is a civil enginear graduated in mysore but no opportunites so he came to dubai,increase in number of old age homes in india is very painfull but the elder people wont adjust to their children they are so possesive that they wont allow their sons to be happy with their wifes it is my own expreince after my marraiage my husbands father do not want me to leave with my husband for that he played many tricks he made me to continue my education and after marriage my husband went to dubai then he started torchering me i was not allowed to talk to my husband over the phone for 1 second and never applied to my passport and started teeling that i am “abnormal” and i have to adjust to him because my husband was brought up in that atmosphere he used to moniter my each and every activity after reading the news paper i have to mark the news and put the date sign and time i read the paper he played many hoocks so that i can cannot get my passport and tried to get me into mental hospital and conveince my husband that i am not well after so much sufffering then i came here many in laws do not trat their daughter-in-laws well and they think that the girls will “steal” their sons from them, elder genration shhould see younger generation with love and wramth and all inlaws should leave this feeling then the situation will improve.
LikeLike
Materialism and the drive to fulfill insatiable “life standards” defined by the media have resulted in this scenario. Indeed a good effort by Dr. Anya & Co. I guess it is still not very late to wake up and make up for the loss, but it will require a collective effort, where I myself have to make a start my making an introspection and working towards building a stronger & loving & caring approach towards elders and relatives and society in general.
LikeLike
I agree with putti thereis also another face of this problem which people are not looking deeply and properly Ihave seen parentswho are not at all satisfied with the children’s care taking there demand s go high and high in all possible matters , I have also seen the parents who were just worrried about the” money ” or materials which children bought they just don’t bother to talk with the children.. or tdiscuss anything with children
Whe n u have everything including money why don’t u call the children and talk to them if u are missing them why don’t elderly make a move?
Emptynest syndrome alwaysattached with the old age so be prepared.I don’t think it is the problem of small towns b’cause if children go out of country then it is the problem everywhere so don’t blame children alone there might be some fault of parents also so look at that face also.
Anyway Iappreciate DR Anya &co for their efforts
BVythe way there was a writeup in churmuri i think last year by MR Bapu Srinivasarao Asking children Why they interfere inparents wish to stay in old age home ? is it not the other face of this this problem
LikeLike
We were just told about this website by Dr. Javeed Nayeem this evening and went through all the comments. Thanks to all those who wrote words of encouragement for our venture. And Manju, no! this is not being treated as a business venture at all! As the article states, it’s on a no-profit-no-loss basis. (So far we have got only one serious candidate, 80 years old, who comes about once a week to enquire whether others have registered…… He wants someone to talk to and spend time – he gets bored at home because his children and grandchildren are most of the time busy with their own engagements and don’t have much time for him.
Putti and Simple are right. There are often tensions between the generations which are caused by simple differences of opinion. Actually the day care would also be good for such people because, at least for a while, the elders would have other things to think about and to engage themselves with, while the youngsters can have a little respite and get along with their work uninterrupted/ undisturbed (we can take the brunt of the elders’ dissatisfactions during that time).
We are also ready to take in people for overnight stay for a few days at a time, and because of lack of any real response for the day-care and short-stay options, we are now thinking we may need to have maybe two full-time resident elders there, to give the place some life!
If anyone has any other suggestions, we will be happy to hear from you.
And, RRK, who are you?
LikeLike
an eye opener for the youngsters…
LikeLike