First Global, the brokerage promoted by Shankar Sharma and Devina Mehra which had a 14.50 per cent stake in the webzine Tehelka, has scored a major victory with official documents reportedly showing that the firm had been harassed by market regulators on trumped-up charges, after the Atal Behari Vajpayee government was shamed by a Tehelka expose that caught the then BJP president taking a cash bribe on camera.
According to a story in Business Standard, official documents obtained from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) under the Right to Information (RTI) Act show that First Global had no “advance knowledge” of the stock market crash of March 2001 that followed the Tehelka story.
Titled “Operation Westend“, the investigation by journalists Aniruddha Bahal and Matthew Samuel resulted in the resignation of the then BJP chief Bangaru Laxman, defence minister George Fernandes, and plenty of egg on the BJP’s face.
The expose resulted in a massive witchhunt against the webzine and its promoters although First Global did not attend the editorial or board meetings, wasn’t in the know of Operation Westend, and was in fact in the process of exiting its investment in Tehelka six months before the story aired.
Documents obtained under RTI show that the brokerage—the first Asian firm outside of Japan to become a member of the London Stock Exchange —had no role in hammering down the stock markets. In fact, it did not figure in the list of the top-50 sellers from mid-February to mid-March 2001, and was in fact a net buyer of Rs 37 crore in the period between the Union budget and the Tehelka expose, a fact not contested by SEBI.
But, because of its links to Tehelka, First Global was stripped off its registration; Shankar Sharma and his wife and partner Devina (a former Business India journalist) were arrested as they were about to board a flight to London (Shankar was arrested two more times); and hundreds of cases were lodged against the duo in an extraordinary act of political vendetta that eventually resulted in the closure of Tehelka before its resurrection as an offline magazine.
First Global, which “paid more taxes than companies like Proctor & Gamble, Ranbaxy, and Titan“, was also forced to shut shop. Worse, the promoters were served over 200 personal summons, raided 25 times, banned from trading, forbidden from travelling abroad, and their accounts frozen.
The assault on Tehelka resulting in its closure, was one of two standout cases of media harassment by the former BJP government, whose prime ministerial candidate L.K. Advani was recently decorated by India’s leading English language broadcaster NDTV with a “lifetime achievement” award.
“Always in favour of anti-terrorism laws, he abolished Press Censorship and repealed anti-press legislation during his tenure in 1977-1979 as the I&B Minister,” read the citation. Advani is also credited for his Emergency era comment on the Indian press: “When you were only asked to bend, many of you chose to crawl.”
Photograph: courtesy rediff.com
Also read: The witch-hunt against First Global
There were cases against one of tehelka’s promoter by Tax department, which UPA did not follow up. They were supposed to pay many 100s of crores to Govt which they did not pay. I think that was first global.
No story is complete without the version of the otherside.
Why Business Standard did not contact/present view of Jaitley/Arun Shourie on the same report? Its highly onesided version.
Indian press has miles to go before it catches up with how standard reporting is done by representing views from both sides.
LikeLike
All in the name of Ram! Will they ever be forgiven?
LikeLike
Well highlighted,Churumuri. The way Tehelka was hounded, harassed and forced to go out of business for pointing out corrupt defence practices is an example of fascist tendencies that most governments in India (more so, the Left-led and BJP ones) display. The Congress led the way with the Emergency in 1975. Thanks to the Internet revolution, this sort of official goondaism is far less effective these days. But, no doubt, governments and parties have no respect for anyone holding a different opinion or asking uncomfortable questions.
LikeLike
Now we know what the SEBI was doing while Raju-garu was helping himself to Satyam’s coffers…
LikeLike
BJP, once a disciplined party, let the power corrupt it. And more importantly it has shown its intolerance of any belief system other than its own. When Vajpayee was in power he could control it, but now it is acting like a rabid dog.
It doesn’t deserve to govern a country like India. least of all Advani.
It seems to be full of leaders like Modi, Advani, VS Acharya etc. Who hector others about morality, while their own MP’s wives commit suicide or murdered! These husbands are virtuous and people who carry out their everyday life without bothering anyone else are of lesser morals!!
And we will always have people like Acharya to justify ‘half murder’ in what is a clear case of Domestic harassment related suicide (Padmapriya), and accident death (in case of Mrs. Yediyurappa, which is any thing but accidental)
It is an open secret in D.K. that Yediyurappa offered Rs.1crore to Puttur Leader Shakuntala Shetty, to withdraw as a BJP rebel candidate. Ms Sheety is one of the popular leaders in puttur, but she wasn’t given a ticket, because she’d have been a rival to ‘MISS’ Karandlaje. Personal Interest Yediyurappa took in that case is indeed very curious.
It is a crying shame that these worthies claim to represent Hindutva! And these guys have spoiled once respected and disciplined party like BJP.
LikeLike
First and third are irrelevant comments! You are pointing out fly in BJP’s plate, when the Congress plate has a donkey in it. (This is an approximate translation of a kannada proverb!). You are perhaps unaware that this was a leaf taken out of Indira “emergency’ Gandhi’s book, who hounded Indian Express, as Ramanath Goenka refused to toe Indira Line. (Hari shows this awareness). Neither action is justifiable. But, there is no need to think that BJP pioneered in this matter.
Incidentally, what has Ram got to do with this matter?
LikeLike
BJP once claimed that it is a party with values and ideals – a party with a difference. But they have proved to be worse than the congress in their corruption and backward vision.
V.S. Acharya is a disgrace to the state and nation. It has been eight months of disaster from the home ministry – Padmapriya case, Yeddy’e wife’s accident, church attacks, bangalore bombing, ram sene pub attacks.
The BJP in karnataka came to power because of the money power of the mining lobby and also with the sympathy factor courtesy the deception of deve gowda and sons. But now with the Pub attacks and molestation of women and the justification they have shown their true colors. BJP is digging its own grave. It will loose all popular support it had.
LikeLike
No story is complete without the version of the otherside.
Why Business Standard did not contact/present view of Jaitley/Arun Shourie on the same report? Its highly onesided version.
Indian press has miles to go before it catches up with how standard reporting is done by representing views from both sides.
LikeLike
Hari,
Please don’t blame the tehelka failure on BJP. I was a subscriber and it is useless left, extreme left of center magazine. I discontinued it.
And Congress/left parties are no saints when it comes to gagging the free press in India.
LikeLike
If Tehelka is a holy cow, why it had stoop to the level of Pink cheddi campaign? Creator of this frivolous campaign, belongs to Tehelka!
LikeLike
serves them right! people will now think twice about bankrolling yellow journalism. should also serve as a warning to the other tehelkas and karavali ales out there.
LikeLike
the tehelka team are full of frauds. remember the recent expose of teesta
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/sc-affidavit-wrong-didnt-know-what-we-signed-riot-victim/399007/
Nothing wrong if they get hounded. Pseudo – freenfair press deserves it.
LikeLike
The comment about crawling, etc. was made by George Fernandes. I don’t remember his having resigned as a result of Thelka’s immensely courageous and imaginative investigative journalism.
As for Gururaj’s defence of BJP’s respect for freedom of the press, what is all this talk we have been hearing about the Karnataka Government appointing an ombudsman by way of keeping the press under control?
LikeLike
etvraviraja, sisya, sriranga – sure you will also argue rationally about the women who got beaten up in mangalore – “these women were in the pub drinking and so these immoral types need to be beaten up.” pls, get ur cock outta ur mouth. also, the pink chaddi campaign might sound frivolous but it is better than your useless haranguing around your pot bellies about how those who speak the truth need to be hounded. you need not tell us about that. we know it already. but guess what, we thought it better than sitting the fence and pontificating about self-righteousness, morality & the nature of investigative journalism.
LikeLike
It is half kidnap ie Home ministry new IPC .
George rightly did not resign, any rational person who had heard and seen Tehelka in which Jaya Jaitely is filmed, will have no doubt that they are persons of high integrity.
Even Advani has said that he has seen the reciept book in which Bangaru Laxman has entered the received amount.
Had every Telhelka highlighted the same.
Why have First Global waited so long to file RTI. Is this because it is an Election year.
LikeLike
Dear All,
Nice one Sisya, TM and Sriranga
I think FirstGlobal was guilty as hell and they probably got away because of the ineptitude of Indian police. This was a very high-level conspiracy hatched to derail an elected government. Shankar and Devina covered their tracks fairly well–but thanks to Sucheta Dalal their ‘Amar Kahani; link is here: http://www.rediff.com/money/2001/mar/29dalal.htm
Enjoy!
LikeLike
Better still read the new book by Madhu Trehan on the victimization of tehelka and people connected with it.
LikeLike
Oh!
Many ppl said There was high corruption in defence deal during BJP rule…Is it stopped now? is UPA corruption free govt? may god bless india!
And tehelka is not out on investigative journalism as corruption is low now? ;-).
But in recent survey on corruption, India has slipped down further…Alas! It is becuase of BJP is still around in opposition? Huh….:D
LikeLike
Good post, churumuri. It’s easy to forget these things, but the BJP’s crimes against Tehelka were numerous and heinous.
LikeLike
>>The comment about crawling, etc. was made by George Fernandes. I don’t remember his having resigned as a result of Thelka’s immensely courageous and imaginative investigative journalism.
The comment was made by Advani after emergency. Yes, George did resign, but cameback after few months. The Tehelka was not a media freedom issue. Alleged ‘oppression’ of Tehelka neither qualifies to come anywhere close to emergency, or proven in court of law.
Jury is still out whether its ethical to entice a person with money by frudulent identity, when no fraud taken place in the first place.
Tehelka did many things, and most of those have been rubbished.
Take example of “Coffin Scam” – Pranab Mukherjee himself rubbished this inside Parliament 2 years back as a defense minister.
What happened to “Gujarat Tapes” last year?
LikeLike
This should be investigated with a koDli, uguru ain’t enough!
Hmm… I remember reading about a complaint made by Debashis Basu(Sucheta Dalal’s husband) to PCI about a newspaper publishing something slanderous about them in 2001.
I wonder if this is related to that!
LikeLike
Sebi slaps 1-year ban on Shankar Sharma for fictitious trading
BS Reporter / Mumbai February 14, 2009
http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/sebi-slaps-1-year-banshankar-sharma-for-fictitious-trading/01/54/348979/
He was banner earlier also in 2001.
LikeLike
@TM,
yup.
oops :) Churumuri’s star witness turned out to be a career criminal …
or wait, will we get a post flaming Shankar Sharma now that the UPA gov’t has banned him ? :)
LikeLike
Dear, .. Now, your favorite Shankar Sharma has been banned by SEBI for one year!
So, look who the person is before you start defending someone and start blaming a party/person!
LikeLike
The detailed order of SEBI on Shankar Sharma is here: http://www.sebi.gov.in/cmorder/ShankarSharma.pdf
It transpires in the clause 9 of the order that Sharma engaged in “fictitious trading” by taking “opposite positions” in 10 odd stocks where “exchange of ownership never actually take place.”
Thats staright-forward criminal.
The motive could be many. Bringing the stock market down can be one of them. It could even be sabotaging the genuine trade in these stocks or …… Motive is really immaterial here. Its illegal activity.
But somehow, Sharma’s friends in the media seem to be painting the image of a “political martyr” for him.
Maybe thats the way our country works. Once you become a criminal, you can then aspire for “political immunity” as long as you have “reserves” to impress the party treasurer.
Whether it is Shankar Sharma or Ramalingam Raju, the modus operandi is similar. Only that for Raju, his reserves vanished in thin air.
LikeLike
Thx Salty for the SEBI link.
Tragedy of India is, nothing will happen. Even this will not be reported prominently in all sections of media.
I feel so sad the way a section of media conducts itself. We can understand why politicians conduct corrupt, but why media does not speak the TRUTH?
Like politicians (and proposed for judges), every year annual income, asset details of every major newspaper editor, reporters should be made mandatory and be brought under RTI.
LikeLike
Churumuri has egg on its face now.
As suggested before, better stick to photos of Yeddy falling over chairs and snigger. Economics, Media, Politics etc is not your cup of tea.
LikeLike