B.S. NAGARAJ writes from New Delhi: Cricket’s ultra-pyjama version, Champions League T20 tournament, got off to a glitzy start on Thursday. Chaka Khan, Shaggy and Jameila, and not to forget our own A.R. Rahman, crooned and danced.
“I Feel for You,” they sang, their voices reverberating across the M. Chinnaswamy Stadium through 5,000 MW speakers.
The report in Deccan Herald was suitably gushing:
“The fusion of art forms from East and West was symbolic of the message the 16-day tournament conveys, a global cricketing village and the desire to uphold the spirit of the game.”
We talk of the world being a global village, but what about the worst-ever flood in a century in our own backyard? How have our cricketers responded to this monstrous calamity in Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh? What about the “feel” for your people?
One hasn’t come across announcements of any big donation, either from the stars or from the cash-rich cricket associations so far. This is what Lalit Modi, who deserves a good deal of the credit for vulgarising the game, had to say when asked whether there would be a donation for flood relief from the tournament earnings:
“This is a calamity that has hit our nation and we will seriously examine it … this is something that is on the cards for discussion in the next few days.”
Mr Modi, do you need a discussion to write out a cheque for a few crores out of the thousands that the Champions League and Indian Premier League which you head rake in?
The other day, when chief minister B.S. Yediyurappa went round the by-lanes of Chickpet and Balepet in Bangalore, the response was spontaneous. The Karnataka garment association presented a cheque for Rs 4.5 lakh, the electrical merchants association Rs 10 lakh, and the Bangalore switchgear manufacturers association Rs 1.71 lakh.
A coconut vendor is said to have dropped Rs 150 into the donation box, while an old woman took a wad of notes from her seragu as her contribution. And here you have Lalit Modi saying he would have a “discussion” with his Australian and South African counterparts over the next few days on the issue!
And what about the stars?
Anil Kumble, Rahul Dravid and Robin Uthappa are the three biggies from Karnataka playing the tournament. We haven’t heard from them either. If they had only spared a few minutes before the match began to go round the stands with a donation box, a good deal of money could have mobilised.
Or they could have put up their autographs for sale, just as they put themselves up for auction in the IPL bidding rounds.
Nobody grudges the cricketers their millions by way of match fees, endorsements, and players’ auctions. But there is something called CSR or cricketers’ social responsibility too.
Photograph: The opening ceremony of the Championship League Twenty20 at Chinnaswamy stadium in Bangalore on Thursday (Karnataka Photo News)
Even the USA government , having substantial US corporate interests in AP & Karnataka, gave a cheque of 50 Lakhs for the flood victims.
Lalit Modi decision is getting delayed because he might still be negotiating telecasting rights (of the “cheque giving ceremony to CM”) with the channels.
LikeLike
I don’t think they have any intention of doing anything. If they had, they would have already drummed and thumped all around singing about their charity. The worst is, the next tax season you can see them queuing up to get their reward money or reward car to be exempted from tax.
LikeLike
Why blame the players or even the organizers. You should blame crores of bakras who are patronizing them blindly, madly, foolishly. ಮೋಸ ಹೋಗುವವನು ಇರೋವರೆಗೆ ಮೋಸ ಮಾಡುವವನು ಹುಟ್ತಾನೆ ಇರ್ತಾನೆ. And what about the media. Are they not publishing full page ads that too on the front page of the dailies, thus glorifying non-events? I think the media should start “Jago Grahak Jago” series. For once, George Bernard Shaw was right when he is supposed to have remarked “cricket is a game played by 11 players and watched by 11000 fools. (now you can safely make it 11 crore).
LikeLike
Here we go again – trying to teach celebrities/sport stars what they should or shouldn’t be doing!? Why? They are human beings too and can decide for themselves what they should be doing and whether or not they should contribute to a cause. Why should churumuri judge?
LikeLike
Life has to go on irrespecive. Irrespective of that, somehow cannot but agree with the broad theme that the author brings about.
Read in the newspapers that a couple of southafrican fans who were shopping in the city donated some money as the CM’s cavalcade was going through that area.
LikeLike
while andhra pradesh and karnataka are going through a very difficult time, and the contributions of concerned people must be appreciated, i don’t get this trend of publicly displaying how much one’s heart bleeds for the victims – where one has to be ‘seen’ doing the right thing.
rahul dravid and anil kumble have consistently come across as dignified individuals. not making a public display of their concern–by carrying a donation box– is no yardstick to judge them. politicians, on the other hand, are happy to make a public display, simply because it suits their agenda. lets not compare them.
and as far ‘vulgarising’ the game of cricket is concerned, well, let market forces determine that. if people don’t like the new format, stadiums won’t get filled and advertisers won’t rush to buy spots on tv channels. in any liberal, democratic society, you can’t be forced to buy something you don’t like. that wasn’t the case on thursday night, when RCB took on Cape Cobras in a packed stadium.
all said and done, T20 has given an opportunity for young talent to overcome the hurdles of Ranji state selection committee politics (virender sehwag recently went public about his problems with the selectors of the delhi ranji team.) so while lalit modi and his cohorts in the BCCI aren’t angels by any stretch of imagination, this is one thing they managed to get right.
LikeLike
I dont understand when charity became a necessity. You should appreciate when people donate, but criticizing people who dot donate is plain wrong! Each one of us could always do more for the society than we do. So we should be constantly blaming ourselves. We do not live in a utopian society where everyone thinks of the poor and downtrodden. We live in a society where you think about yourselves first. Please lets all agree to respect the actual meaning of the word, “charity”.
LikeLike
Exactly! As Anupama says, why this need to ‘teach’ and ‘preach’ others what they should be doing?!! They are adult human beings and are responsible for their own lives. If they want to ‘help’ other human beings they would have done so, without even telling others. Instead of poking our long, thick and dirty noses into what others ( read monetarily successful people) have done to ‘uplift’ other people, ask what I have done to have even the right to ‘preach’ others? Seriously and amazingly WTF stuff!!!
LikeLike
Janasamanya,
Let us be bakras. Since we are not capable of much at sport – maybe we can just take pleasure looks at our flanneled fools.
Anupama,
Why shouldnt churumuri judge?
LikeLike
I second Mahesh here…..
A coconut vendor is said to have dropped Rs 150 into the donation box, while an old woman took a wad of notes from her seragu as her contribution. And here you have Lalit Modi saying he would have a “discussion” with his Australian and South African counterparts over the next few days on the issue!
It is silly to draw such a comparison…. Mr. Modi would have his own obligations. If he’s a willing person, he would donate. But that isn’t any reason to criticize him or any celebrity of any walk of life….
It serves well as long as we think abt what maximum ‘we’ can do…… Sport is sport.. Entertainment is entertainment.. Personal is personal… lets not jumble all this up…
@Janasamanya
Your point of view is kinda ironical to the word ‘janasamanya’ … :) Jus kidding
If one person talks abt 11000 or 11 crore ppl being fools, Who is the fool? It is such an easy answer… :P
Cheers..!!
Arjun
LikeLike
Anil Kumble participated in a relief money collection drive and has asked BCCI to hold a charity match between Deccan Chargers and RCB for the beneift of flood victims and a charity match between film stars and cricketers.
LikeLike
@YellaOK, The piece of information given by you is heartening. It is so much better to hear this than things like “it is their money and their wish” and it is a personal decision to donate. After all, there is something called “giving back.”
A light tap on the conscience of the well-heeled at times like this will do no harm.
LikeLike
@ Arjun
Just because 11000 or even 11crore ppl follow it, a foolish thing wont turn into a wise thing.. :)
@ Anupama
Of course there is a need to judge what these celebrities do. Maybe U and I dont idealize them but there are millions out there who worship them. These celebrities actually need not contribute a lot personally, i am sure if they just urge ppl to lend their hand the flow of money to the relief fund will increase.
LikeLike
I would not go to the extent of naming individuals but it would be a great gesture if the IPL organisers could do something to contribute to flood relief. In that respect the charity match between RCB and the Chargers would be a fitting tribute as these teams actually represent the states KA and AP and should be wholeheartedly welcomed.
LikeLike
Money begets lack of nationalistic feelings, feelings for brethren, and sportsmanship. See here :
http://24dunia.com/english-news/cricket-news/showgroup/4199335.html
This is the insensitivity that makes a Lalit Modi and cricket stars totally indifferent to the world around them.
LikeLike
I agree with what the article says. But its time to not point fingers and see what we can do as individuals. On that note, I have created a group on Facebook for flood relief efforts. I update it with any info I find on how people can contribute towards the efforts. On Facebook, please search for “Andhra & Karnataka flood relief”.
LikeLike