Arun Shourie, the BJP’s resident intellectual for all matters requiring “an IQ of more than 60“—in the famous words of P. Chidambaram, presumably the Congress’s resident intellectual for all matters requiring an IQ of less than 600—has a piece in today’s Indian Express on the debacle of the BJP in the 2009 general elections.
The Magsaysay Award winning journalist, who has emerged as the third man in the dissident triangle after Jaswant Singh and Yashwant Sinha, strikes the grand posture of speaking for all the parties but leaves little doubt over why the L.K. Advani-Arun Jaitley camp has begun to distrust him as to sideline him along with the other two.
“The factor most responsible for the rout has been the state to which the leader and his circle have reduced the party as an organisation, but that is the one factor which the leader and his cohorts will not admit into the discourse. Is the party seen as, is it in fact different from the others? Are its candidates any different? Is every unit of the party not riddled with factionalism?
“That these are the reasons for the setback is manifest to all. But the leader and his circle would have none of them — for that would immediately raise further questions. The party is no longer different from others? Who has allowed the party to sink to this level where it cannot be distinguished from the very parties it has been denouncing? The candidates are no better than those of the rivals? Who has selected the candidates? Factionalism has been allowed to continue? Each state faction has a line to some ringleader in the central cabal? Who has allowed the factionalism to fester and swell?
“They blame others — the rival party; the third party that has stolen their vote; the accidental reason on account of which a section whose vote was to have split got consolidated; the youth; the middle class; the poor who voted on money, the rich who did not vote; the holidays on account of which so many went out of town; the disenchantment with the party’s ally in one state, the absence of an ally in the other; the anti-incumbency factor against us in this state, the advantage that the rival party had in the adjacent state of being in office and thereby being able to use the state machinery; the ‘shameless’ use of money and muscle by the rival… In a word, everyone and everything other than themselves.”
Read the full article here: On the way down
Also read: Don’t laugh: Do journalists make good politicians?
No need to give too much coolness to that quip of that shyster of a minister.
BJP needs to show the middle finger to everything and start working as a decent opposition.
It’d be good if the journalists of today show even a fraction of the zeal that Shourie and his colleagues showed during emergency.
Let them be servile or hostile to any party but they should at least be above the sensationalist and banal reporting.
LikeLike
BJP-bashing article after such a long time. I was missing the good old days of June ’09.
For a while I was wondering if the 2010 Padma* award was slipping out from our Churumuri editors hand.
LikeLike
The hysterics of Cheddis are indeed alarming, First Ad-vani casting “doubts” on Electronic voting machine and now the shoor of shourie.
Why did you guys take panga with a sikh in first plcae!!!, what was the need to taunt him with “nikamma”???
Did the sikh shown them royally or what!! But wait he is not finished, he winked at Delhi High court and they obliged. Now everything is legal.
LikeLike
The islamist on board’s diatribe against Shourie is understandable, given that Shourie has penned a great book called the World of Fatwa’s where he exposes the idiocy of the peaceful religion and its followers ;)
LikeLike
And the diatribe of one of the many cheddis is understandable too. More to come I guess :)
LikeLike
haha, what a farcical blog
LikeLike
There is no chance that someone in churumuri’s party shall ever be able to criticize the Empress of the Prince charming, so they are reduced to celebrating democracy in their opposition :)
LikeLike
The islamist on board’s diatribe against Shourie is understandable,
Who that might be??
Also the defination of “diatribe” is wanted, as none gone attacking Shourie the “rebel” in the comments.
But then again it might be involuntary natural reaction of the Cheddis to cry “hurt”, “victimised”, blah blah everytime thay see the “NAME”.
LikeLike
To the Islamist on board,
The hysterics of Cheddis are indeed alarming, First Ad-vani casting “doubts” on Electronic voting machine and now the shoor of shourie.
//You won’t understand these things because this is Democracy. In a Mullacracy people will stay quiet and believe ‘Earth is flat!’//
Why did you guys take panga with a sikh in first plcae!!!, what was the need to taunt him with “nikamma”???
/
/Recent joint statement with Pak has proved beyond doubt that MMS is trying hard to justify the tag of ‘Nikamma’. May be soon MMS will be given a new title, ‘Sitara -e Nikamma’ by his birthplace friends across the border//
Did the sikh shown them royally or what!! But wait he is not finished, he winked at Delhi High court and they obliged. Now everything is legal.
//Once again any one can see traces of ‘Mullahcracy’ understanding of legal procedures in a democracy. Even the Sikhs are angry with him and it is a matter of time before someone throws his shoes at MMS for his recent acts of ‘bravery’ against Pakistan//
LikeLike
Cheddi party out in full force. BTW whose side are you cheddis on? Shourie/Jaswant/Sinha or Advani/Jaitly/Swaraj? Light khakhi or deep?
LikeLike
hang on khan, weren’t you the one who said elections in karnataka were rigged because the bjp won in KA when it lost in other places? remember? please comeback and clarify. thanks.
so far i have not read a single post by churumuri, criticising AS for what he is actually saying or saying why his consclusions are wrong. instead it is always personality attack or some sort of schadenfreude. i guess that is what distiguishes people like Palagummi Sainath and AS from hacks like Vinod Mehta and Karan Thapar. The former actually lose sleep over what they are talking about and are actually in the ring. The latter are cheerleaders on the side – or ‘fans’ if you want to be charitable.
LikeLike
AG, what do you think? Who’s khakhi is light and who’s dark?
LikeLike
@KHAN & AG..
Cheddis are better than being nude… intellectually or otherwise…you get the drift???
LikeLike
Watching,
I dont know, you tell me.
huttadalli,
I dont get the drift, please explain the drift.
LikeLike
Well AG, I saw you propounding the “shades of khakhi” theory and so thought you knew what you were talking about.
LikeLike
May be soon MMS will be given a new title, ‘Sitara -e Nikamma’ by his birthplace friends across the border
Maybe Ad-vani deserve more, for his yomen service(releasing terrorists, sleeping during parliament, agra feciltation for the buther of kargil…etc etc..) to his janmabhoomi -KARACHI.
@tarle
hang on khan, weren’t you the one who said elections in karnataka were rigged because the bjp won in KA when it lost in other places? remember?
NOPE.. cross check with archive, rather than posting from posterior. This perpetual persecution complex is etched from birth to cheddis only.
LikeLike
Watching,
If I knew, I wouldnt ask would I?
LikeLike
That’s right AG. You did not know what you were talking about. Thank you
LikeLike
Khan,
Creating a strawman and then attacking it with vigour is a mark of all cheddis – the open and the closet ones.
LikeLike
pretty sure about it, bcoz i thought about it for a while and so i remember. no time to search right now. so you can have it.
LikeLike
Che che…if you now feel like an emperor without his clothes that doesn’t mean you should blame me who at least wears his cheddi and doesn’t lie about it.Alva AG?
LikeLike
Illa Watching, you can wear or remove your cheddi in private however you want. It is when you expose your khakhi cheddi in public and play your ram-sene, RSS, VHP thing – you are to blame.
LikeLike
AG, nimma argumentGe alignment hogBitide.I’m gonna sleep..yaawn
LikeLike